5 ms·
14 and 15 year olds should not be working in sweatshops. what the hell is wrong with the people defending this? this isn't the pampered western worker vs the av
by peterwwillis 17y ago
14 and 15 year olds should not be working in sweatshops. what the hell is wrong with the people defending this? this isn't the pampered western worker vs the average 3rd world worker, this is kids being forced to go without sleep and effectively without a life for pennies. fuck that. i know most people will argue something like "they are probably lucky to get it." it's still bad for them, and trying to justify the bad conditions with arguments like 'its expected of them' really exposes a true lack of empathy for one's fellow man and some pretty selfish reasoning.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sketerpot 17y agoIf you have a better alternative, do feel free to post your ideas.
- chc 17y agoI have empathy toward them and their harsh circumstances, but the thing I recognize is that the alternatives are mostly WORSE. In opinion writing, one of the key rules is that it's useless to simply complain about something — we have to offer a workable alternative. Failure to do this is one of the reasons why Bush's Iraq War was considered such a failure: He had a hugely successful plan to topple Saddam, but he didn't know where to go from there and lots of people suffered for it. So I feel for people in bad conditions, but it's also important to have perspective about how bad "bad" can be.
- ErrantX 17y agoI can understand your sentiment (Im sure I once shared it too). However please bear in mind this is a huge culture clash problem. Extended visits to the region will throw things in a new light (like it did for myself). Now, clearly, conditions definitely are a problem in many places. However the general theory of working at 14/15 is more of a cultural thing and not an issue. I don't think it's correct to dictate society rules such as "thou must not work under 16" just because we happened to stop that practice several years back. I find it a bit sadistic that we wish to dictate that sentiment to others... Of course us then exploiting that work environment is a whole other problem. Additionally; what's the solution? Stop all these kids working? What are they going to do? Really, seriously? Increased wages would be good - that is certainly something we should encourage.
- Sandman 17y agoAdditionally; what's the solution? Stop all these kids working? What are they going to do? Really, seriously? Umm... I don't know, maybe go to school and get an education like the kids in Europe and the US do, so they can get a better job than this?
- ErrantX 17y agoHeh, see there is the cultural differences right there. An industrial job has little stigma in some parts of the world. Indeed in certain situations it is a big step up from the jobs your parents do. For some those wages are the "better" job (again, not ideal, but you have to consider that as the context). It's not an ideal situation, certainly, and it should be a moral imperative to offer those less well off chances at the same comforts we enjoy. But I dislike the idea of judging the situation based on the rules of our society, that's all.
- krschultz 17y agoIndustrial jobs don't have a stigma in the US to a lot of people either. But in the US a manufacturing job means you work 40 hours a week and get a living wage. There is nothing like this in the US. A job like this is not comparable and is definitely something to want to avoid.
- Sandman 17y agoI agree that we shouldn't judge other cultures based on the standards of our own culture. However, I somehow doubt that kids working 15 hours a day actually prefer that to having more free time. Nobody would work those hours unless they actually had to. And that is the problem. The fact that those kids have to work under these conditions, instead of going to school, hanging out with their friends and so on. Perhaps some of them would actually like to get an education, to work as an engineer, or a scientist, or something else - but they don't even get that chance, they're stuck working on that assembly line.
- ErrantX 17y ago
- dantheman 17y agoNo people like you are bad for these people. People take the best job they can get, because you know what -- it makes their life better. Yeah working hard sucks, but you know what being in poverty sucks more. China is poor, to reach the standard of living found in the west (generated over decades if not centuries) they have to make up a lot of that effort. Technology/Productivity improvements significantly reduce the level of effort required, but eventually work needs to be done. They can build cities, cars, etc -- but they need natural resource imports, so they must trade with the rest of the world. For some things it makes sense to purchase from the outside market, cheaper to purchase than make themselves, so once again they need to make something that the outside values. It's the most efficient use of their time. As for possible inhumane treatment in the form of employer abuse, etc that of course is wrong and a different matter than just working hard.
- eru 17y agoIn Germany you used to start your apprenticeship at age 14.
- peterwwillis 17y agoDo the apprentices work 15 hour shifts 6-7 days a week? If so, I believe that is unhealthy, both mentally and physically, for anyone but especially a person whose body is growing and needs more rest than an older person.
- eru 17y agoFor the post-WWII generations 12 hours 6 days a week should have been the absolute maximum. 8-10 hours 6 days a week (with the 6th day less hours) should have been more normal.