4 ms·
"Security Fatigue", or just plain old drowning? I'm a software engineer and I feel like it's impossible to completely secure my hardware. It's a full time pro
by colordrops 10y ago
"Security Fatigue", or just plain old drowning? I'm a software engineer and I feel like it's impossible to completely secure my hardware. It's a full time professional job to secure a computer, and at some point you just give up and do the best you can, knowing there are probably several holes in your security you aren't even aware of.
- leereeves 10y agoCountless computers secured by full time professionals have been hacked. The safest course is to assume that if it's connected to the Internet, it's not secure.
- robbrown451 10y agoThat may be safe, but seems impractical. I mean, I use email. It would be very, very bad if someone got into my email and started vandalizing my life. I might never know why I was losing friends, or worse. Secure vs. not secure is not a black and white thing.
- hashkb 10y agoYou should get real about how secure your email is, then. Are you using end to end encryption?
- robbrown451 10y agoI use gmail with default settings. This isn't some situation that is unique to me. Most anyone could have their life messed up badly if someone got on their email and wanted to do them harm.
- anf 10y agoIn other words "not end-to-end, but encrypted on all hops for most messages". Is there any evidence of email being intercepted by anyone who would wish to do anyone harm that isn't a public adversary of western intelligence?
- fludlight 10y agoEncryption won't help you when someone installs a key logger on your endpoint.
- justinlardinois 10y agoAs in using PGP or something?
- ythl 10y ago> Countless computers secured by full time professionals have been hacked. And yet, the black hats who breach such systems often have an attitude like "Wow, such a reputable organization has such sorry security. They deserve what I did to them". Computer security is a black hole that will consume ever increasing amounts of money, memory, and cpu cycles, forever. What a waste.
- anf 10y ago> Computer security is a black hole that will consume ever increasing amounts of money, memory, and cpu cycles, forever. What a waste. That is defeatist and false. Computer security done intelligently can raise the cost of an attack above the value of what is being protected.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI agree, a well spent security dollar might make an attack cost $100 more for the assailant. It's classic attrition warfare[0]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attrition_warfare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attrition_warfare
- Spooky23 10y agoNo way. Computer security is like a tax whose returns diminish rapidly. Once you start prioritizing it with money on security vs product/system engineering, security starts turning into a money monster that delivers nothing. I've seen it happen time and time again. The asymmetric nature of raising the cost for an attacker is a red herring. You can pat yourself on the back that you've supposedly made it 100x more expensive to attack you, but one operational fuckup pops that fantasy bubble at any time.
- dom0 10y agoI have to agree here. Security in itself is highly asymmetrical, because any single flaw can prove fatal, even with the latest and greatest defense-in-depth techniques. Not to forget the many, many instances where security systems actively harmed / enabled attacks.
- raesene9 10y agoI don't find thinking of "secure" in an absolute sense really helpful. It all depends on your threat model, so who's going to attack you and what vectors and resources they'll have at their disposal. Sure against nation state level attackers it's fair to say that no-one but the most well funded of groups will be able to entirely avoid compromise, but it's definitely possible to avoid most of the lower end attacks that are more realistically a likelihood for most Internet users.
- raesene9 10y agothat's one of the reasons a lot of security people these days will recommend not just relying on preventative controls, but also detection and response. The assumption that nothing is 100% secure shouldn't lead to people just giving up , but hopefully lead to them spending effort on detecting attempted and successful intrusions and in having effective responses to them.
- jacquesm 10y ago> that's one of the reasons a lot of security people these days will recommend not just relying on preventative controls, but also detection and response. Unfortunately, the parties that need this most are the least likely to implement it. The usual response to a question whether or not intrusion detection or exfiltration dectection / prevention measures are installed is 'What?', which I find a much more scary answer than 'No.'.
- raesene9 10y agooh absolutely, there's a bad problem in security where people don't want to admit there might be a chance their controls aren't perfect, and by deploying better detect/react controls you are very much admitting that point. So there's a tendency to downplay those requirements (what OS or application vendor is going to say "hey you should deploy something for when our security fails on you")
- wodencafe 10y agoWell at this point we're battling several different entities: Domestic Government Agencies, Foreign Government Agencies, various "Secretive Hacking Groups", Hacktivists, Malware, The Prince of Nigeria and other assorted phishing scams, our own Hardware Manufacturers (I'm looking at you, Intel and AMD), people within the network who are careless about their own security and have access to your data, not to mention the usual hits from China and the Middle East. Irony: Every government wants to authorize hacking at the state level, but nobody is rushing to secure their own infrastructure from being hacked.