4 ms·
It's not really strange, if you map maslows heirarchy to a corresponding job (either the outputs or the individual worker satisfaction) then it makes sense to m
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
It's not really strange, if you map maslows heirarchy to a corresponding job (either the outputs or the individual worker satisfaction) then it makes sense to make these moral/honorable distinctions.
The world's Basic needs are realized through industry and agriculture
The worlds Psychological and Self Fulfillment needs are further up and are realized through services.
- dragonwriter 10y agoIIRC, while popularly referenced and in some ways intuitively attractive to many people, Maslow's hierarchy of needs is basically speculation that has never been born out scientifically. So the fact that if one assumes it models reality, then certain observed distinctions people make about jobs are sensible doesn't actually make those distinctions sensible. (Also, psychological and self-fulfillment needs are realized through industry or agriculture [pretty much all luxury products of either kind], and a some Basic needs are realized through services.)
- Kevin_S 10y agoTrue, but I think that the people's perception is what we are discussing here, not what is actually scientifically correct. Students are taught Maslow's hierarchy as fact, so I think it can be assumed that the perception argument is fair here.
- DubiousPusher 10y agoFor me the problem with this isn't the invocation of Maslow's needs but the step to saying that they have some bearing on how people view occupations. I just don't think that's born out at all by reality. Architect which is a very respected profession isn't fully necessary to meet even the basic need of "shelter." You can build a house without an architect but you can't without a builder. While corn farmer and cattle rancher, the underpinning occupations of our food system aren't treated with much respect or reverence at all.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoShouldn't that make service jobs more skilled than factory jobs, and therefore worthy of higher prestige and better pay?
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWell some are. Like doctors. Notice though that service jobs that fit into the basic needs categories are the outliers in this case.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI'm arguing that you've got the direction backwards. I'm asserting that, when the basics - the stuff lower on the hierarchy - is available in abundance, the stuff higher on the hierarchy should pay better than the stuff lower on the hierarchy. For an example, basic food costs less than a ticket to the opera. The opera is higher on the hierarchy.