4 ms·
Obviously laws about clothing are wrong. Do you have any evidence that women are raped for not wearing the hijab? And is that happening any more than in the "
by DanBC 10y ago
Obviously laws about clothing are wrong.
Do you have any evidence that women are raped for not wearing the hijab? And is that happening any more than in the "enlightened Christian" countries, such as the US where people are also raped and murdered for the who they are?
http://www.rrsonline.org/?page_id=944 http://www.rrsonline.org/?page_id=944
eg
>> Most studies reveal that approximately 50% of transgender people experience sexual violence at some point in their lifetime.48
>> The National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs reports that lesbian, gay, bisexual, and queer people were three times more likely to report sexual violence and/or harassment compared to heterosexual people who reported to NCAVP in 2010.49
Surveys regularly show that people think the victims of violent sexual crime are partly to blame if they didn't fight back, or if they were in "the wrong place", or if they were intoxicated.
- frozenport 10y agoThere are numerous authorities on Islam who so say it's "okay" to rape women that don't meet their cultural norms (even if they don't live in their culture). Perhaps OP is referring to this incident http://www.frontpagemag.com/point/180393/muslim-imam-claims-women-who-dont-wear-hijabs-are-daniel-greenfield http://www.frontpagemag.com/point/180393/muslim-imam-claims-...
- hackuser 10y agoThere are people everywhere that say it and in poorer countries, I believe, that and other sanctioned violence generally is more common. I'd have to see some data to believe it's more than another ugly rumor, the kind that go with widespread prejudice, that such things are more common in Muslim communities. Certainly, these days, almost anything bad that can be associated with Islam is covered and is spun that way. I would request a different cite than FrontPage Mag, which appears to put a large banner at the top of every page saying 'Inside every liberal is a totalitarian screaming to get out'.
- Chris2048 10y agoThere is a big difference between a comment like that from some you-tube troll, and from a religious leader or imam/cleric.
- hackuser 10y agoDefinitely. But religious leaders in the West say such things too. I was looking for another video I once saw as an example, but this list should be familiar: https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=preacher%20gay%20kill%20him%20and%20tell%20god%20he%20died%20site%3Ayoutube.com https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=preacher%20gay%2... There are wackos everywhere, in every religion and town and country. When it's in our world, we have the cultural knowledge to know how much threat they really represent. When we see "Iranian Imam says ...", is that the equivalent of the Pope? Some fringe but powerful archbishop? A broad consensus? The strip mall preacher? And not just fringe people but American leaders say hateful things, from mayors to governors to a guy who has a serious chance of being elected president.
- frozenport 10y agoThe real lesson is that all extant religions are bad :-)
- Chris2048 10y agoMaybe we lack the context in many cases, but do we not know Iran to be a place where such thoughts have legs? I don't have much love for the pope either, but I feel that he at least has some political restrictions in west. > American leaders say hateful things, from mayors to governors to a guy who has a serious chance of being elected president Trump seems to be a little different from past candidates though, and "American leaders say hateful things" lacks magnitude - what percentage of leaders, and how was this perceived? For most, even the impression of racism is a career ender, and they are under a great deal of scrutiny.
- Chris2048 10y ago> didn't fight back, or if they were in "the wrong place", or if they were intoxicated Entirely different. If I take a big risk, I might be partly to blame for a negative outcome. If I do something immoral, I might be blamed for the negative consequence. But these are not the same semantics for blame; One says I should have been more diligent in avoiding harm; The other says I actually deserve harm. Conflating the two, or willingly ignoring the nuance is a liberal trick. There are, despite liberal perception, few people that say someone intoxicated actually deserves to be assaulted, this is usually something put in peoples mouths. Meanwhile, this is very much the opinion wrt the Hijab - that the women are immodest and deserve punishment. Show me a westerner that believes assault is a reasonable punishment for intoxication, and I'll show you crowd of westerners that despises them.
- hackuser 10y agoFirst: The strawman, stereotype 'liberals' - they aren't like real people. Given a chance, people don't really fit in those boxes (conservative ones either); they are nuanced and have a mismash of beliefs, and aren't trying to trick anyone. Just like you and me. > If I take a big risk, I might be partly to blame for a negative outcome. If I do something immoral, I might be blamed for the negative consequence. I think you are right about risks and outcomes, but not how it applies. First, just in terms of your theory, what's the difference between a woman in London who doesn't cover up her skirt late at night, takes a risk, and gets assaulted, and a woman in Tehran who doesn't cover up her skirt with a hajib, takes a risk, and gets assaulted? (Bear with me ...) * Note that many in the U.S. will say, 'she asked for it', and not just to their buddies. There are endless reports of law enforcement taking this attitude when rape victims report the crime and harassing them, to the degree that rape victims often don't report it. It's an official, if unwritten rule, to a meaningful degree. * In Iran it's a written rule (I assume). Some in Iran will say she deserved it, as you noted for religious reasons. But I read that in Egypt, at least, a basis for that rule (I don't know how common, or if this is somehow religiously-based) is that women who don't cover up are tempting men, who can't be expected to resist. That's pretty similar to 'she asked for it'. I think to a great degree it may be the same thinking, just rationalized and implemented in different ways in a secular and in a religious society. Either way, she violated social norms - men's rules about what she can do with her body - and deserves what she gets.
- dogma1138 10y agoIn the major cities they have a modesty police http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2016/05/03/476511439/springtime-in-iran-means-the-morality-police-are-out-in-force http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2016/05/03/476511439/s... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guidance_Patrol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guidance_Patrol https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/apr/20/influx-of-morality-police-to-patrol-the-streets-of-tehran https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/apr/20/influx-of-mora... In the less-developed regions it's usually gangs policing with which do apply violence and these have been growing in the west also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharia_patrols https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharia_patrols You can search youtube for the results, it's way to vile and NSFW to post it on HN.
- Nursie 10y agoI'm glad others have responded to you with some evidence, I have seen some of it before but am going mostly on stories from Iranian family members who have been arrested and harassed and subject to physical violence for not covering their hair properly. Yes, it is much, much worse than in places like the US, it is carried out by state agencies like the morality police and by pseudo-state entities like the "Basij". As others pointed out, when you.move outside the cities things often get less 'civilised' I understand that people don't want to fall into the trap of prejudice, but things are materially worse in places like Iran, and drawing parallels with how women are treated in the west is not helpful. We have problems, we don't have the morality police or relgious militias, at least here in the UK