4 ms·
> Multiple companies could set up, some with ad-free paid options, others funded by advertising. OK. But why would they? What is the raison d'etre for such a
by eropple 10y ago
> Multiple companies could set up, some with ad-free paid options, others funded by advertising.
OK. But why would they? What is the raison d'etre for such a company to exist? What is the competitive advantage here for those companies to actually do that? How does this not turn into a hilarious race-to-the-bottom that zeroes out any reason for anybody to do it in the first place?
I am profoundly unconvinced that you're going to ever beat a Twitter or a Facebook and it's not because of "vested interests preventing it", it's because the current options meet the needs and desires of the userbase. The size of the group that cares about self-hosting something like this is within epsilon of zero percent. Because nobody cares, there is no network effect to pull other people.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIt turns into a utility, like Wikipedia, or OpenStreetMap. Not all that provides value generates profit, hence the need for a different model. Mind you, Telegram is funded by one wealthy benefactor, and I'd argue its a reasonably large service not attempting to compete for profit against other incumbents.
- KirinDave 10y ago> It turns into a utility, like Wikipedia, or OpenStreetMap. Not all that provides value generates profit, hence the need for a different model. The only conceivable reason it would is if individual providers found value data mining it.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoOpenStreetMap infrastructure only costs $200K/year to run. A microblogging platform can't come up with $200K/year?
- coldtea 10y agoYou make it sound trivial. Where would it come up with $200/K year?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI'd propose crowdfunding the first $200k to gauge interest before committing resources, and then move to a subscription model ($1-5/user/year). WhatsApp had success at that price point, which leads me to believe $1/year would not be a hard sell for those interested in an ongoing microblogging platform. Note: Twitter has ~313 million active monthly users. Only 0.0006 percent of those users would need to find interest in this sort of new platform for it to be viable (at the price point I mention above).
- coldtea 10y ago>which leads me to believe $1/year would not be a hard sell for those interested in an ongoing microblogging platform. That's the hard part. Why would they be interested? There are tons of microblogging platforms available.
- KirinDave 10y agoBut twitter has a global timeline, spends lots of money on user acquisition and partnerships with major corporations to broadcast and manage events. Even if we assume that $200m/yr from OSM (which has a much easier job than Twitter, scaling) is reasonable, this new system people are proposing lacks a lot of fundamental discovery features that make Twitter valuable. And yet again, even if they are addressed then this means many more people would need to pitch in for the initial customer acquisition and community building. I know many people at Twitter who labor to do exactly that sort of thing to this very day. People buidling these networks think their technology is what's valuable, and there is a threshold of scale you have to meet (which btw, I do not think the projects involved here have demonstrated), but after that it's the community that has the real value. My experience with Mastodon is a blank screen with a single message from me, "I wonder how I meet people here?" Even the word "microblogging" captures fundamentally the wrong idea about what drives the core of twitter's community and engagement.
- 10y ago
- eropple 10y agoThat model still needs users, then. "It's self-hosting" does not provide any kind of user story for, say, me. I have Twitter. Twitter works. This adds nothing to the experience and subtracts about a kerjillion people from the pool.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI agree that self-hosting isn't a story, but an underlying feature. You have Twitter. Twitter works. For now. Will it when Disney acquires it? Or some other corporate suitor?
- lazerwalker 10y agoSay Twitter gets acquired and subsequently completely fucked up (not that the latter necessarily follows from the former), and there's now a market void. What're the odds the "winner" of the ensuing fight is the decentralized FOSS platform — that has very real tangible benefits, but ones that are hard to explain to an average user — over the shiny new VC-funded Twitter clone that can throw hundreds of thousands of dollars at user acquisition?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI have no idea how to fight the never ending torrent of VC money funding clone after clone after clone.
- zanny 10y agoTime. It is only "worth it" for the one VC that wins the winner take all rat race. There can only be so much stupid money in the world before only the smart people are left with any.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- bduerst 10y agoWikipedia became the user standard because the competitors (encyclopedias) didn't have an online presence. This would be more akin to trying to create a new, decentralized wikipedia now, to compete with the centralized wikipedia.
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoIt is notable that MediaWiki[0] is a decentralised / self-hosted Wikipedia. Of course, it is also what Wikipedia runs on. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MediaWiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MediaWiki
- rakoo 10y ago> decentralised / self-hosted Those are not the same thing. "Decentralised" implies that the functionality is provided by a bunch of nodes that communicate together. A MediaWiki instance is a single website that doesn't communicate to other MediaWiki instances for its functionality. Smallest Federated Wiki (https://wardcunningham.github.io/ https://wardcunningham.github.io/) is closer to what a decentralised wiki software would be.
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoIt depends. I would have done better to put decentralised in quotes myself. It was being used to refer to the fact that a company wiki isn't under a central authorities control. This was the common contextual usage of decentralised in this thread (stemming from the fact that all twitter accounts are under a central authorities control). "decentralised" is such a mess of a term by itself.
- eropple 10y ago"Decentralized", in computing, is pretty unambiguous. My Postgres database isn't "decentralized" because I run my own instance of Postgres. My Zookeeper cluster is "decentralized" because I can shoot nodes dead and the remaining ones will handle their business as far as continuing operation.
- erikb 10y agoLife is not just about making money. And even making money becomes easier if you have done something cool and recognizable in the past. At the very least you can use it on your resume, or when coordinating the team at your start-up, or as a foundation to start a conference career.