3 ms·
Even the number "50mm" is massively debated. The 51.6mm number is drawn from the focal length of classic Leica normal lenses, which is 100% arbitrary. There's
by paulmd 10y ago
Even the number "50mm" is massively debated. The 51.6mm number is drawn from the focal length of classic Leica normal lenses, which is 100% arbitrary. There's pretty strong arguments that something more like 43mm is the normal focal length for 35mm.
And designing lenses with adequate coverage for 35mm as well as a sufficient flange distance to clear a SLR mirror was definitely a problem back in the day. Older "normal" lenses for SLRs used to commonly be 55mm or even 58mm. Wide angle-lenses suffered a similar problem, and for a great while rangefinder lenses (or similar lenses that protruded into the mirror cavity of a SLR) were the dominant options for wide angle photography.
It took quite a while to develop good "retrofocal" lenses where the optical center is actually behind the lens (basically the opposite of the telephoto lens where the optical center is in front of the lens). The very first examples of the type are the Angénieux retrofocus and the Voigtländer Prominent's Skoparon, both introduced in 1950. The Skoparon design was essentially a Tessar lens backwards and went on to be one of the earliest wide-angle lenses used in SLRs, notably as the Asahi Pentax 35mm f/3.5. It had an extremely long lifespan, in its medium-format variant (Pentax 75mm f/4.5) it continued to be produced until around 2000. The funny thing is it all happened because Voigtländer patented it for rangefinders but neglected to patent it for SLRs!
The other thing to remember about 50mm-ish macro lenses is that it's still somewhat reasonable to build a helicoid that can get out to 1:1 reproduction without extension tubes. I have a 50mm and a 90mm that will both go to 1:1 reproduction on their own, and I can tell you that while the 50mm may be somewhat ungainly the 90mm is absolutely absurd when you crank it all the way out. The 50mm uses a double helicoid, the 90mm is actually four helicoids running inside each other.
- dom0 10y agoYes, the old unit focusing macro designs can look rather weird and somewhat unstable when fully "racked out". With internal focusing this has been "fixed", although they still need a lot of displacement of the focusing group (in the Nikon 200/4 AF for example it's about five cm if I remember right, which is a lot for an IF design). Most macros still have a lot of external movement, but internally floating elements reduce the required displacement still. (E.g. Tokina 100/2.8, about 6 cm displacement of the main groups, since helicoil - a cam our two for tiny adjustments of two other groups.