2 ms·
Are the article's quotes and comments about Wolfe's treatment of Darwin accurate? I'm not a big Chomsky fan. On the other hand, using Everett as an attack on
by mcguire 10y ago
Are the article's quotes and comments about Wolfe's treatment of Darwin accurate?
I'm not a big Chomsky fan. On the other hand, using Everett as an attack on Chomsky doesn't work; Everett is a bit sketchy and one language does not provide a counter example.
But I admit I haven't studied Chomsky in detail. I do know a fair bit about Darwin, though, and if this is accurate, Wolfe's whole book can be discarded without fear of missing anything.
- jnevill 10y agoIt's accurate. This book is being ripped apart by scholars across many different disciplines. It's a lovely piece of trash that makes Wolfe look as bad as this article suggests.