2 ms·
...until it's broken into. I suspect that chances of would-be burglars or identity thieves breaking into Google data are pretty slim, in comparison to a home-i
by nine_k 10y ago
...until it's broken into.
I suspect that chances of would-be burglars or identity thieves breaking into Google data are pretty slim, in comparison to a home-installed system.
OTOH both Google and a private person can be strong-armed by a court order, or even a three-letter agency, to open up their AI knowledge vaults.
- arca_vorago 10y agoIm more worried about turn key totalitarian nation states having this info and then being able to walk the cat back.
- jrowley 10y agoExactly. For example, see the news yesterday with Yahoo. Imagine instead of just emails, it was all of the data about all of us.
- joncrocks 10y agoThe difference is one of targeting. It's like saying "People would never break into a bank, when they could break into someone's house and steal their stuff" It may be easier to break into someone's home-brew system, but generally it would be unlikely to happen unless you were being otherwise targetted. Whereas google has a lot of users data, which could make it a more attractive target.
- nine_k 10y agoVery much so! If you're a "person of interest", you'll be attacked either way. If you're just a regular person, like me, you won't likely be targeted. But my chances of getting a collateral damage are much higher in a centralized system: when it's broken into, my data have a chance of being siphoned off along with data of someone less ordinary, who was the target of the attack.
- infogulch 10y agoIt's wider than this. A "person of interest" will be attacked either way. A "normal boring person" won't be targeted directly, but may be swept up in an attack on a "person of interest". But there's a third case: "normal boring people" become interesting just by being together in a big group, even if no particular "person of interest" is among them.
- tbrownaw 10y agoIt may be easier to break into someone's home-brew system, but generally it would be unlikely to happen unless you were being otherwise targetted. Just how "home-brew" are we talking here? If there's any web-facing code that you didn't write yourself, whether commercial or open-source or whatever, that's a target for attackers that just scan everything looking for known vulnerable services. If it is entirely custom, I'm fairly sure there are a few classes of common security errors that can be reasonably well tested for without direct human involvement. Which brings back the threat of attackers just scanning for all available targets.
- zeveb 10y ago> I suspect that chances of would-be burglars or identity thieves breaking into Google data are pretty slim, in comparison to a home-installed system. The odds of someone physically taking my computer and decrypting my data are zero (128-bit encryption for the win!). The odds of someone electronically breaking into my computer are higher. The odds of my data being misused or misaccessed at Google are one: it will happen.