28 ms·
Why would anyone want to buy Twitter? Sure they have a great brand, loyal fans, but pretty much no way to monetizing them. It's pretty obvious that Twitter has
by mrweasel 10y ago
Why would anyone want to buy Twitter? Sure they have a great brand, loyal fans, but pretty much no way to monetizing them.
It's pretty obvious that Twitter has access to tons of interesting data, I just question if it's anything more than simply "interesting". While Twitter is huge, it's not really ubiquitous enough that you can use it for measuring things like effectiveness of marketing campaigns.
- untog 10y agoHow many news stories are there every day about a politician or a celebrity tweeting about X? Just because it isn't monetisable doesn't mean it isn't valuable to the right (media, probably) organisation.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIf it's valuable, isn't it monetizable?
- mrweasel 10y agoIt you can't monetise it, then how valuable it that data really? It doesn't matter how valuable your product is, if no one is willing to pay. Perhaps the gossip magazines should pool their money and buy Twitter?
- proksoup 10y agoJust editorial control over the line of "what's acceptable here" is a huge power to control the boundaries of debate. That power can be used to make massive amounts of money.
- mrweasel 10y agoSo why aren't Twitter profitable? Because Jack Dorsey is a nice guy, or not smart enough?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- untog 10y agoMonetisation usually implies end users paying for a product. I don't think Twitter will ever get to that point. But a media company like Disney (who, remember, own ESPN) could absolutely capitalise on the value of Twitter for live sports, for example. It would be valuable to them.
- mrweasel 10y agoCouldn't they do that now... for free? What's the benefit to buying Twitter? If it's due to missing functionality they could probably just pay Twitter to implement the features they're missing and it would be cheaper than buying them outright, while providing a safety net in case it fails. Right now you're suggesting that e.g. Disney is buying Twitter, for 17 billion dollars, to implement an untested business case. The cost of failure in that case is at least the purchase price of Twitter, that seems like a massive gamble.
- untog 10y agoBeing able to control the entire direction of a company is a lot more powerful than just paying them to add functionality. It also grants the ability to lock competitors out of the service once you've proved the new functionality is a success. I don't think Twitter is worth $17bn, but we live in an era of excessively hyped up and unrealistic valuations, so I have no idea what the correct price actually is. Yes, buying Twitter is a gamble, but many acquisitions are.
- jpindar 10y agoThey recently did an awesome job of streaming an NFL game.
- seibelj 10y agoRich people buy assets that allow them to influence the world or simply have it as a trophy. See Bezos and WaPo, John Henry and Boston Globe, Carlos Slim and the NYT. I totally see someone famous buying Twitter just to own it, or another company like Disney who just wants it to break-even. It has cultural and influential value now separate from profit.
- SwellJoe 10y agoGiven how many of the valley's biggest thought leaders use Twitter very heavily, I'd be surprised if there weren't a lot of potential buyers. Then again, its value is high enough to shake out a lot of the smaller players, since the buy-in is pretty astronomically huge. If the valley is an echo chamber (it is), then Twitter echoes louder than most things I can think of. Very few companies have the kind of reach and influence within the valley that Twitter has.
- inverse_pi 10y agoTheir revenue is 2.2B.
- mrweasel 10y agoFair enough, they have some small way of monetizing, which is 400 - 500 million USD short of covering their operating cost.
- spullara 10y agoThe operating cost is somewhat arbitrary and if a company like Google bought them there is almost 100% overlap on the technology and ads side. Only thing that would be twitter specific would be product.
- sulam 10y agoI don't know if you're using the accounting terminology correctly here. Their GAAP costs are higher than revenue, but a very large percentage of that is compensation, and almost all of that compensation is stock grants. If the stock were to go to zero, the company would immediately be profitable, even if everything else stays the same.
- rco8786 10y ago> but pretty much no way to monetizing them. I don't understand why people keep saying this. Twitter has multiple billions of dollars in revenue from monetizing their users. Profitable? No. They built out a massive organization planning for user growth comparable to how fast Facebook was growing, but user growth stalled. There is a profitable business within Twitter, but someone has to be willing to do the gut job.
- alfalfasprout 10y agoEh, Google buying them makes a ton of sense. 1. Massive access to a social network that can better integrate all their products. 2. Integration with their ad platform (improving monetization enough to make it break-even). 3. They'd own one of the most influential social networks in the world. Google buzz, Google wave, Google + were all massive failures. 4. Integration with things like Google News. They'd be able to understand trends almost perfectly (from both news stories and users). I think people on HN and the like sometimes massively underestimate why Twitter is so important. Twitter as a big social network like Facebook is never going to happen. Their decision to pursue that route seems foolish in retrospect. Instead, what Twitter has is a smaller group of users that are extremely influential. Moreover, they have the most effective fan-out messaging platform in existence. I think focusing on monetization/user only makes sense while TWTR is an independent company. Companies like GOOG, MSFT, etc. benefit greatly from the externalities of owning TWTR more than the business itself (consider Youtube, for example).
- fullshark 10y agoWhat about Salesforce, I don't get that one.