5 ms·
Well, that was kind of a burn. Was the argument by the bankers basically a complaint that retooling would be very expensive? and/or that employee surveillance
by pmarreck 10y ago
Well, that was kind of a burn.
Was the argument by the bankers basically a complaint that retooling would be very expensive? and/or that employee surveillance would be more difficult? (yeah, I'm sure everyone is a fan of that!)
- brazzledazzle 10y agomitm surveillance of employee traffic is basically a cornerstone of enterprise security since those networks are designed to be very squishy on the inside. Thankfully Google is turning the assumption that the perimeter needs to extend to your rather vulnerable clients on its head but that will be several years before it's productized enough that middle managers will be convinced to buy it by a VAR over a game of golf.
- fulafel 10y agoHighly culture and jurisdiction dependent. Many places ban this with some narrow exceptions (defense sector etc) in law and/or binding labour org agreements.
- ChoHag 10y agoThat's basically putting the cart before the horse. Security is hard. Hard problems are easier when there are fewer of them. It's easier to build one big wall than lots of little ones. Surveillance of employees is a cornerstone of enterprise security because humans are inherently untrustworthy. One part of the solution to this problem is to define a distinction (using golf[+] of all things as an analogy) between the rough, the fairway and the green. Because defining a border between the rough and the course is easy, and untrustworthy humans aren't all that bad most of the time, the distinction between the fairway and the green easily becomes blurred. While employers may polish up the distinction between their workaday desktops and their locked-down servers they will never abandon the difference, and nor should they, between their systems and everyone else's systems. [+] You have my permission to use this analogy with your manglers.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoJust to be clear I'm referring to monitoring traffic for security threats. Not for things like stealing source code or applying for jobs or whatever BS some employers are paranoid about. The reason it's a cornerstone is because your clients, especially laptops, are huge gaping attack vectors. They visit other networks and browse the web. Even if they're browsing the web 100% of the time through a web proxy it's not going to catch everything. And it's for that same reason Google decided to shrink their perimeter. The distinction between their systems and someone else's is still maintained, but they've accepted and embraced the fact that the laptops used by their employees can and will get owned. So instead of acting as a bridge between the internet and internal squishy networks they sit out there with the internet. But I'm hardly doing the concept justice. In fact I'm probably hurting it more than helping it. If you haven't read it Google discusses the security concepts in a short paper you can get here: http://research.google.com/pubs/pub43231.html http://research.google.com/pubs/pub43231.html
- serge2k 10y agoIt sounds like required surveillance though. The problem here is really they were way, way, behind on getting their concerns out there.
- superuser2 10y ago>I'm sure everyone is a fan of that! Are you a fan of laws like "people who sell you financial products are not permitted to lie" and "financial institutions must make an effort to ensure that their salesmen are not lying to customers" or at least "there need to be records so we can sort it out on the lawsuit after the fact"? That's one of the main things employee surveillance is for in financial services.
- adekok 10y ago> Was the argument by the bankers basically a complaint that retooling would be very expensive? Yes. Everyone else should be more vulnerable to MitM attacks and insecurities, because it's too expensive for them to fix their endpoints. I don't care. Security protocols are hard enough to design correctly, without adding crap like that. And, I don't care enough about their crappy business model to support it by giving up some of my security. It's 2016, people. Grow up, or get out.
- Tharkun 10y agoBanks don't like spending money. And their IT infrastructre tends to be awful.