3 ms·
The U.S. has terrible terrible rail systems. Lack of transport causes people to cluster, especially if you're disabled or need public transport. Jenna, Germany
by djsumdog 10y ago
The U.S. has terrible terrible rail systems. Lack of transport causes people to cluster, especially if you're disabled or need public transport.
Jenna, Germany. 100k people. 4 trams. 3 intercity stations, one with an ICE line.
Chattanooga, TN. 200k. The Chattanooga choo-choo from the song has no trains. Not even an AmTrak. Even talk of a train to Atlanta got everyone angry because they didn't want Atlanta commuters.
I don't understand why Americans love their cars so much and hate rail.
- jschwartzi 10y agoIt's not that we like cars, it's just that we don't see why anyone else should benefit from our tax dollars. Rail seems to be a direct subsidy to the poor, even though it removes drivers from the roads. The rail projects where I live all seem to argue that it will make it more convenient for people to commute by public transit, which is the wrong argument. They should actually be arguing that it will remove other drivers from the road, making more room for people who don't have access.
- ams6110 10y agoIt's not quite that it's an unwanted subsidy to the poor, it's that is something that is seen as useless. I like my cars, I don't like/don't use the train, therefore I do not support trains.
- mattmcknight 10y agoIt's not just that. Building rail in the US is insanely expensive. http://www.realclearpolicy.com/blog/2015/03/31/high_costs_may_explain_crumbling_support_for_us_infrastructure_1249.html http://www.realclearpolicy.com/blog/2015/03/31/high_costs_ma...
- bmm6o 10y agoBuilding rail lines is a "subsidy for the poor", but building highways is "investing in infrastructure". We Americans are crazy.
- CalRobert 10y agoEven where the US has good rail, it's good rail on top of crappy cities. Plot the London Underground in LA and it still wouldn't work for most people because they live 10 times further away from their destinations. The average speed of the underground isn't even that high, really, but for most journeys you don't need to go that far. Conversely, plop LA's rail system on London and it would be far more effective than it is in LA, because you could actually be near the things you wanted to visit when you stepped off the platform, instead of 4 more miles away from them. I mean, seriously, LA built a light rail station a mile away from the airport and called it "Aviation station", yet using it to get to the airport is a sheer misery of unlabeled buses and bad schedules.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]