6 ms·
I greatly enjoyed reading this, although the author takes (more than) a few liberties when comparing the Roman and the various Asian empires: > Imperial Rome w
by woodruffw 10y ago
I greatly enjoyed reading this, although the author takes (more than) a few liberties when comparing the Roman and the various Asian empires:
> Imperial Rome was a dim backwater by comparison
This is a slippery claim, especially when you consider how long the Roman Empire lasted and how widely its relevance and regional dominance swayed over its lifetime. During its peak, Rome spanned dozens of cultures on two separate continents and liberally imported other peoples and norms into their own. That's not to say that the contemporaneous Chinese empires didn't do the same, only that the distinction between the two in this aspect is less stark than the author would have us believe.
> Rome’s legions were fighting fiercely for control of Gaul (modern France and Germany), Britain, Egypt, and various parts of the Balkans; while a succession of (often unfairly maligned) emperors scrambled to hold Rome together through an endless series of famines, wars with the East, coups d’état, refugee crises, and revolts.
This is not strictly false, but it's again muddied by the extreme duration of the Roman Empire. The Pax Romana lasted for two centuries, spanned three major political dynasties, and is generally the period people think of when they think of the Roman Empire (or Rome in general). By the time the Chinese Empire(s) had begun trading silk with the Roman Empire, peace was already the norm in the Roman world.
The author is correct in his characterization of Rome as less artistically and creatively inclined than it perhaps ought to have been, considering its size and wealth during its peak. That being said, Rome's accomplishments in architecture and culture are visible (and audible) everywhere in the Western world. I don't think that any one Eastern power of the same period can claim such cultural permanence to any comparable degree.
- Red_Tarsius 10y agoI flagged the article. The author exploited clickbait titles and western guilt to craft his own narrative. People are going to read this poor cluster of pop history and get a very wrong idea of the Roman Empire. The second part of the article was quite fascinating but how can I possibly trust the author after statements such as Imperial Rome was a dim backwater by comparison. The premise of the article is flawed too, we don't know enough about the 'chinese' skeletons yet: http://www.forbes.com/forbes/welcome/?toURL=http://www.forbes.com/sites/kristinakillgrove/2016/09/23/chinese-skeletons-in-roman-britain-not-so-fast/&refURL=https://www.google.it/&referrer=https://www.google.it/ http://www.forbes.com/forbes/welcome/?toURL=http://www.forbe... "The truth is, though, that Rome’s Asian contemporaries completely dwarfed Rome in almost every respect: heritage, population, cultural diversity, technology, architecture, medicine, philosophy, poetry… I could go on, but you get the idea." Read this article with a grain of salt.
- 1457389 10y ago>how can I possibly trust the author after statements such as Imperial Rome was a dim backwater by comparison. Well you could read the rest of the article and see if the statements hold up...I see nothing in your comment that justified what was essentially censorship on your part.
- woodruffw 10y agoI don't think that was necessary. There's a few points where he exaggerates or otherwise overstates comparative claims about Rome, but his research into the antiquity cultures of Asia Minor/the Middle East is both accurate and refreshing considering how little recognition they get outside of anthropology and (specialized) classics. The comparison of contemporary Chinese and Roman power is also a valuable one - it's not often brought up in either one's respective historical studies. It's worth keeping in mind that this is a Medium post by a blogger. It's not peer reviewed, and it should be read with the author's opinions and goals in mind.
- soufron 10y agoWell, his "research" amounts to some quick reading of wikipedia articles... and that's it.
- hesarenu 10y agoYou don't need to trust the second part look up wiki on ancient Indian and Chinese empires.
- 1474295912 10y agoIt's unfortunate that you flagged the article and let your bias take over. The article, ignoring mislabeling of images, is still a work of research. > Imperial Rome was a dim backwater by comparison. And it was, by comparison. Why do people have the audacity to think that Rome alone was greater in all aspects than the collective synergy of Persia, India, China, Swahili Coast etc? These regions were in extensive trade and cultural contacts and the cold hard truth is we Europeans were not a central part of that scheme. That's why Asians devised decimal system, paper currency, and wooden block printing, compass, and other ground-breaking inventions, due to its sheer vibrancy.
- muro 10y agoThe Roman Empire was on 3 continents :)