6 ms·
They can park their cars in their own driveways or land they own. Where's the problem?
by davidw 10y ago
They can park their cars in their own driveways or land they own. Where's the problem?
- Tarrosion 10y agoWhere I live (Cambridge), many people rent an apartment that doesn't come with a parking spot. Instead these people pay the city for a street parking permit. Hypothetically the city ensures that the number of permits matches available supply, though prevention of illegal parking is difficult and sporadic. Anyway, these people rely on their vehicles for transportation to work or school, and they pay for a parking spot. If a huge influx of drivers arrived without corresponding parking supply increases, I'm not sure these folks would be able to reliably park near their homes or get to work. We can imagine solutions involving increasing the street permit price, etc., but fundamentally more drivers without more supply (road* and parking) is bad for current drivers. *insert warning about Braess paradox and induced demand.
- davidw 10y agoMaybe in that case they'd be willing to pay a bit more for a more guaranteed spot - like something they actually own or something they are sure of. In a free-market-ish system, perhaps people would build more parking at that point. Seems like an example of an "economic calculation problem": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem
- ghaff 10y agoCambridge has also historically been pretty hostile toward building parking garages. Parking permits were pretty cheap but garage parking was very limited and very expensive. So it's not really a free-market-ish system. Agree with the basic point which is essentially how things work in areas like Manhattan where people can't generally depend on inexpensive on-street parking.
- jacalata 10y agoit's only a fundamental problem if you already decided that the obvious solution (policing the illegally parked cars) is impossible. New residents owning cars which they cannot park on the street without being towed would not affect current permit holders at all. Sure, policing might not be done now. But is that because it's not worth doing/nobody cares enough, or because there is some law of physics which makes it impossible? Even a street sweep every few days immediately after most people arrive home from work would massively change the risks of parking illegally.
- CalRobert 10y agoThe solution is the same as it always is when lots of people want a scarce resource. Increase the price, or increase supply. If parking is expensive someone can open a lot, or a garage, and turn a profit. Parking on my street is very limited, so the spots are expensive. This way there's often at least one available. If there isn't, I can park around the corner in a privately-owned garage. Nobody says you can't build new apartments because they expect parking welfare at their neighbours' expense. The problem is that most people feel it's perfectly reasonable to expect to claim a bit of land _for free_ for their car - if I just built a second house on a parking spot people wouldn't say "well the solution is to limit park-house-permits to local residents", they would demand I buy land on which to place my house.
- jcriddle4 10y agoSmall lots means no garage or even driveway so street front park is all you get. Imagine forking over several hundred thousand for a house and then a few years later finding out that you cannot park in front of your own home like you have done for years.
- chris_7 10y agoIf this was important to you, why not purchase land with a private spot, instead of presuming continued free private use of a public resource?
- jcriddle4 10y agoWell lots of people can barely afford a home let alone try and get a home with a garage or driveway. In addition how do home owners anticipate that some nearby development, 5 or 10 years later, is going to go in without parking? Especially since the city council on several occasions has promised to require a reasonable amount of parking for new buildings.
- twblalock 10y ago> In addition how do home owners anticipate that some nearby development, 5 or 10 years later, is going to go in without parking? You can't anticipate it, which is why you should never view street parking as a guaranteed feature of your home. People who can't afford homes with garages or driveways just need to be realistic about the fact that the parking situation on their street might change in the future. Similarly, all homeowners, whether they have garages and driveways or not, need to be realistic about the fact that many things in their neighborhood might change, including density and traffic. That's just life. You can't fully control what happens on land you don't own.
- nitrogen 10y agoAs someone who grew up in a low density area this just seems bizarre to me, the idea that an outsider might have more right than you to the curb that is maintained with your property taxes. Almost as bizarre is the idea of houses without driveways.