11 ms·
Background: http://www.develop-online.net/news/squad-devs-blast-kerbal-space-program-studio-for-high-crunch-and-low-pay/0220059 http://www.develop-online.net/ne
by empath75 10y ago
Background: http://www.develop-online.net/news/squad-devs-blast-kerbal-space-program-studio-for-high-crunch-and-low-pay/0220059 http://www.develop-online.net/news/squad-devs-blast-kerbal-s...
- jessaustin 10y agoWow it's kind of amazing that USA-based coders signed up for a $2400 annual salary!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- asimuvPR 10y ago$2400 a year? What US dev works for that in this market? You are better off at burger king.
- nine_k 10y agoThis is $200 a month; unless you work part-time, it's likely illegal.
- duaneb 10y agoThis is only as an employee. You're free to contract your own rate at whatever you'd like (including for free); while "salary" implies a full employment that doesn't look like the case here. EDIT: none of what I said applies; this was in Mexico.
- nine_k 10y agoWhile I may agree with some criticisms of minimum wages, there are jurisdictions that mandate a minimum hourly rate. Most of the US states are such jurisdictions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bigiain 10y agoJurisdictions are quite important when deciding whether something's "illegal". Seems like that's twice the minimum wage where it happened (just from reading the post/comments), so it's extremely unlikely to be "illegal" where it happened. (it's a curious question as to whether there's anything illegal, and if so, on who's part, if a Mexican business is paying above-local-minimum wage salaries to people who are not local. If you _accept_ a remote job where the renumeration is disclosed but below your local minimum wage - I wonder if any law has been broken, and if so, by who?)
- sandworm101 10y ago>>If you _accept_ a remote job where the renumeration is disclosed but below your local minimum wage - I wonder if any law has been broken, and if so, by who? Yes. That is a crime. The employee has committed a crime by negotiation/accepting the wage. The employer has too. Regardless of where they think they "work" they are employing someone standing in the other jurisdiction. If one allows offshore companies to bypass wage laws then every single local company would be run through an offshore shell, negating the local law. So it is near-universal that offshores must comply with local wage laws. In practical terms, a flesh-and-blood 'employee' isn't going to be prosecuted. That side of things is reserved for sub-contracting entities that aren't real people. Negotiating a sub-minimum wage contract remains a crime for subcontractors. This is necessary to prevent one-person "companies" negotiating illegal pay for their one employee under the fiction that they are an arms-length subcontractor when everyone knows the person is effectively an employee.
- lazaroclapp 10y agoNone should, but this is ~2x the Mexican minimum wage. I guess the question here (as per nine_k comment) becomes, if you are working remotely, for a position listed in country A, but you are located in country B, do country B's minimum wage laws apply? If so, does that mean the company in country A should pay you a higher wage, or simply means you don't qualify for the position (note that developer positions in Mexico with Mexican companies are often advertised with offer details such as the salary, in a way that is not common in the U.S.) Edit: huge correction on the multiplier on minimum wage. For some reason I had been comparing monthly rates with annual ones and arriving at 24x. Upon careful examination, that is ridiculous, but the overall point remains. With the correction, this is actually hugely subpar wages for developers even in Mexico, but not quite illegal wages... for reference, entry level dev work at software companies might be around $20,000 MXP, which is currently $1,000 USD monthly.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Vanit 10y ago$2400 is their annual wage, not monthly. Only 2x
- daeken 10y ago24x the Mexican minimum wage would be $28.8k. This is 2x minimum wage.
- lazaroclapp 10y agoShit, I didn't read the annually versus monthly part... corrected in the original, with edit note.
- kevindong 10y agoFarther into the article: > To be fair to Squad, the Mexican minimum wage is about $100 USD monthly, so they weren't technically paying anyone lower than the minimum wage...
- asimuvPR 10y agoSome were US based developers who could have gotten more money as dish washers. I don't get this.
- meowface 10y agoMoreover, they know they were directly working on a game that made at least (1.5M * 39.99) ~60 million USD. I admire dedication to one's work and love of the game and all, but that's just not rational.
- sidlls 10y agoWhat about working for literally nothing? Like, say, open source?
- asimuvPR 10y agoIn open source you keep the rights. Which for this game probably means millions. They did not get the rights or Rúe money. It just baffles me to no end.
- sidlls 10y agoKeeping the rights to something you're giving away for free is the definition of meaningless symbolism in this context.
- esrauch 10y agoNot that it justifies anything but that is probably a significant overestimate, Steam takes 30% and most people didn't pay full price for the game.
- dethstar 10y agoUsing current exchange rates that's about 3850 MXN a month. That sounds like what my friend made as a cashier here in Mexico. Very shitty payment, even for this country. A good entry level job starts at about 10k a month.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoA homeless beggar can clear $2400 a year easy; that's less than $7 a day. You're essentially working for free at that point. I don't understand why they ever agreed to it, at least not without some sort of profit-sharing thing.
- bigiain 10y agoMaybe because: July 2015 - Oct 2016: Lead Engineer, Squad Delivered Kerbal Space program version 1.2 on time and on budget. Managed team of 5 geographically distributed developers and graphic artists. Reduced defect count by 17% Reads way better than: July 2015 - Oct 2016: Panhandler, Mission and 16th Achieved 11% month on month growth in revenue. Exceeded all set goals and milestones. Migrated from crack to high grade Bolivian cocaine without incurring mob debt or serious personal injury. ;-) (Though with a little more polishing and embellishment, I bet you could get that second entry past a typical recruiter... Maybe change to "July 2015 - Oct 2016: Growth Hacking Contractor, Bay Area Startup still in stealth mode (under NDA)... " and "Migrated from legacy processes to best practice agile methodology without incurring technical debt or serious downtime." - there, that ought to do it...)
- ryandrake 10y agoHard to judge without knowing the full story. There are many possible reasons for taking a job with less than average pay. Tough job market, lots of competition, wanting to get some (any) experience on the resume. It's not like plum, high paying tech jobs are growing on trees, despite what you might hear about the mythical "shortage of developers".
- josephagoss 10y agoActually worse, beggars on the street make more money.
- btym 10y ago>“$2,400 was my yearly salary working a full time eight hours a day, 40 hours a week job.” Why would you ever choose to work there in the first place?
- vkou 10y agoBecause you're 21, and want to make video games, and live with your parents?
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoFor coders thinking they'll just build something cool? This is your competition.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Mikushi 10y agoMore reasons to evolve your career away from coding, it's a dead end by 35, you'll just be outcompeted on so many fronts.
- emodendroket 10y agoAnd do what instead? Where is that not an issue?
- zapu 10y agoProbably, yes. I'm guilty of taking jobs like these in the past as well.
- usrusr 10y agoSounds reasonable. We might be talking about a modder or someone in other ways deeply invested in the community who is given pocket change each month as some kind of hobby stipend. Which is perfectly all right precisely up to the moment where anyone involved starts to think of it as a full time gig, maybe a career even. The failure on the side of squad then isn't so much in not paying them more (although that would certainly be one way to solve it), it's in not realizing that there can't be a middle ground. What I don't get at all, no matter how you spin the story, is how anybody could be forced to overtime etc on pocket change. Sure, that stuff happens millions of times each day, but it would typically involve people at the brink of starvation in an isolated mining town or so. Remote tech workers with enough leisure time to fall deep into the rabbit hole of gaming don't quite fit that pattern.
- cheez 10y agoWell, with such a good game behind them, I'm sure they'll find other paying work. Or maybe they can just take the whole studio and make a new game.
- Camillo 10y agoOr click through to the original posts: https://imgur.com/a/9Lf86#5JQABQG https://imgur.com/a/9Lf86#5JQABQG One thing that most people in this thread seem to be confused about: PDtv, the guy making $2400/year, was a "Media Director", not a developer.
- jasonwatkinspdx 10y agoFirst a disclaimer: I have no idea what's going on with KGS or any inside info. I'm just speculating, please treat it as such. As a generalization when a significant group from a successful game walks out en mass, it's because they feel the owners aren't fairly sharing profits. Letting this happen is usually a really dumb move by the owners. A great example is the Medal of Honor franchise, which raised a studio best known for a nice quake expansion to the top of the industry. The owners did not treat the team in a way the team considered fair. The bulk walked out, signed a deal with another publisher to become their own studio, and the Call of Duty franchise was born. I think most people are aware that CoD has made an obscene amount of money. It's hard to believe that whatever selfish split the MoH owners were getting justified not having any split of that team's later work. When you have a team that has proven they can hit the top, the last thing to do is treat them as disposable.
- jasonwatkinspdx 10y agosigh... s/KGS/KSP/ my apologies, I can't edit the prior comment.
- Razengan 10y agoYou play Go, I take it? https://www.gokgs.com/ https://www.gokgs.com/
- jasonwatkinspdx 10y agoI don't any longer, but yes, at one time I was pretty regular on KGS, hence the habit typo. :D
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 10y agoIt has been years for me as well (mostly due to the Java Runtime requirement which I'm usually loathe to install.) The highest achievement of my amateur career must have been tying with a 1-Dan once. :) I wonder why this game hasn't seen a resurgence (in the West) on today's mobile devices yet.
- LandoCalrissian 10y agoI hope the devs found their own studio and make a competing product. I feel like they could potentially make more money and an even better game.