3 ms·
Are mentally ill people capable of deciding of what's in their best interests? Children? That's confounding the issue with an orthogonal question. We already h
by tremon 10y ago
Are mentally ill people capable of deciding of what's in their best interests? Children?
That's confounding the issue with an orthogonal question. We already have the means to measure and control mental capacity before the law: it's called legal guardianship.
If children are allowed legal euthanasia, should they be able to decide independent of their parents or guardians?
"Decide" is a bit ambiguous for me. Yes, they should reach their own decision independently; and no, their decision alone is not reason enough to go through with it.
Could their parents or guardians so decide without the child's consent?
"Without" is a bit ambiguous for me. Yes, if consent cannot be ascertained from the child (e.g. coma, paralysis), that should be possible; and no, "against the child's wishes" should never be allowed.
Should there be any age limit at all?
I simply don't believe in universal hard limits. There will always be corner cases where what's "right" falls on the wrong side of them.
Especially in the case of voluntary termination, I believe that every case is a tragedy in itself, and every case should stand on its own arguments and merits. To do any less would be a disservice to the suffering.
Conversely, to put an age limit on voluntary termination to me feels like mandating by law that young people can't suffer (i.e. I think it amounts to using the law to create the illusion of a perfect world).