12 ms·
What New York Can Learn from Barcelona’s ‘Superblocks’
- nerdponx 10y agoMy question is whether this will help or hurt access by the elderly and disabled to supermarkets and other big-box stores like Home Depot.
- wefarrell 10y agoManhattan doesn't have many supermarkets or big box stores, certainly not in the areas the article references.
- lmkg 10y agoAccess to supermarkets and big-box stores isn't as necessary when if streets are lined with small grocery stores and other retailers. Assuming the zoning allows it, I would think the increased pedestrian traffic makes those types of stores more sustainable.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoWell, that and the premium prices they charge.
- spodek 10y agoLess the cost of a car, less the time you have to go out of your way to go to a box store, less the space in your apartment to store the stuff. I live in the West Village and just got back from picking up my weekly farm delivery six blocks away. The vegetables were picked probably in the last 36 hours and are consistently the most delicious I've tasted, including compared to my parents' gardens, where I can eat them off the vine. I walked to the pickup place and back in less time I've seen people wait in line, or even walk from their car to the entrance of a supermarket.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoIf you're living in NYC, the difference you pay in rent, compared to say, Los Angeles, is greater than the TCO of a new car.
- icebraining 10y agoIsn't that generally proportional to the cost of living of the whole neighborhood?
- CodeWriter23 10y agoNot really. When I lived in SoHo, we would walk an extra 5 blocks each way to shop at the Grand Union because the pricing was significantly different shopping at a place with more buying power.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoIt's an interesting question, though it is somewhat suburb-centric. In NYC, the elderly and disabled have no natural access to these kinds of services unless they live a block or two away from such an establishment, for the simple reason that hardly anyone living in NYC owns a car. Yes, they can take a cab, and that makes it feasible, but economically speaking, the most common outcome is these people are dependent on the bodega on their block to provide their food.
- avani 10y agoI see no reason to automatically equate "elderly and disabled" with "poor" (bodega?!). Ubers/Lyfts are not terribly expensive compared to owning and maintaining a car+insurance in the city, especially if only used for shopping and not commuting.
- c0riander 10y agoIn NYC, small grocery stores (i.e. one of many retail storefronts on a block) are often colloquially referred to as bodegas, no matter the economic status of the area.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI have to second the other guy. There's no negative stigma associated with the word "bodega". It's just a small store that sells a large variety of random goods, including food, and that is run as a small business (i.e. it isn't a national chain). They're everywhere, in all neighborhoods.
- nerdponx 10y agoWell said, but I actually had the UES in mind, specifically as compared to the UWS, which always seemed much more accessible by comparison. More trains, fewer hills, and better spacing-out of services. But the socioeconomic make-up is also very different, so it might be a non-issue.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI disagree, I see a lot of elderly people pushing around some pretty sizable grocery hauls in wheeled carts in NYC. When you're retired and you don't have anything else to do with your time, then walking some extra blocks to go to a real grocery store and save money and get better product is absolutely worth it. People live longer in Manhattan than anywhere else in the United States. Part of that has to do with people continuing to be active and getting exercise at older ages. And grocery runs count. But you're definitely right that hardly anyone owns a car.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Symbiote 10y agoIn the long term, if elderly people are able to be more active (walking etc) they're going to have a better quality of life. The reduction in air pollution will also help. The elderly people (>75) I know don't often go to places like Home Depot. In Barcelona supermarkets will be within walking distance -- if I've found the correct area on Google Maps, there are at least 3 within 300 metres of each other.
- JackFr 10y agoIn Manhattan everyone delivers.
- chris_7 10y agoWell, just this morning a driver killed an elderly person in Manhattan! She certainly won't be going to the supermarket anymore! (and this isn't a rare occurrence) http://gothamist.com/2016/10/04/pedestrian_killed_by_bus_driver_on.php http://gothamist.com/2016/10/04/pedestrian_killed_by_bus_dri...
- collyw 10y agoBarcelona is a very dense city and you usually don't need to go "driving distance" to find a supermarket.
- rayiner 10y agoThis would be harder to do in New York because the blocks are very long east-to-west. It's a third of a mile from 6th avenue to 8th avenue. It'd be easy to shut down a bunch of the east-to-west streets (which are often pretty quiet anyway), but you'd lose a lot of the utility of the superblock without an internal north-south pedestrian route connecting them.
- chris_7 10y agoThis can partially be fixed by significantly expanding the sidewalks on the avenues (especially in Midtown). Take them down to 1 bus/emergency lane, 1 private car lane, and some loading zones (where there aren't bus stops), which will also help with induced demand.
- Ericson2314 10y agoAdd mid block cross walks too, or just allow pedestrians everywhere unless there's an emergency vehicle.
- chris_7 10y agoThat's basically just legalizing the current behavior!
- CydeWeys 10y agoI see your point, but NYC pedestrians tend to make up for it by simply walking fast (with the highest average pedestrian walking speed of any city in North America). The really long blocks have always seemed like a questionable decision to me.
- sotojuan 10y agoI'm not sure how this might work considering the fact that trucks are taking stuff to and from Manhattan businesses and homes almost 24/7. Barcelona might be a city, but it's scale and density is nowhere near that of New York. Perhaps I can see this being tested in another borough in an area with lower density.
- cmyr 10y agoI always find it surprising when people, imagining some large change, pick on some current reality and how it would have trouble fitting into the imagined future as some sort of indictment of that future. I would suggest that roads closed to most vehicle traffic would be open to delivery trucks, like in most old european town centres, and or delivery is made by smaller vehicles. In the long-term, I can imagine a new model of city infrastructure that allows easy small-scale delivery with some standardized container system and small electric vehicles.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoThey aren't even suggesting that the interior streets be completely closed, just that the speed limit be reduced to 5 mph and pedestrians be given priority. That would make them unattractive if you are trying to get all the way through the block, but if you are trying to drive up to a building inside the block it would only be a minor inconvenience.
- mjevans 10y agoI was hoping for something closer to an arcology, society assimilating disperse buildings in to a more cohesive urban /plan/ that services their transportation needs and encourages high quality space within the middle. This is more like the budget version of that. Don't really solve the big issues, don't really improve the central areas. What would make this better is consolidation; actually moving the parking to the interlink point of the node, making it faster for a pedestrian to get from there to their home, or another point within the node. Improving the center so that it's more of an actual park, possibly with the shopping at level around it. Raising the standard of integration, interaction, and building codes for noise/fire suppression.
- grassclip 10y agoI'm actually in Barcelona at the moment, and it's definitely been easy to walk around, but that could also be because the touristy areas near the ocean are very dense, and day to day living north or west of that hub might be different. Besides the giant blocks for walking (I'm not sure I've found a "superblock", but the blocks I've walked on are huge), there are an incredible amount of mopeds. That seems to be a default way of getting around town for locals. That's a big difference than bikers who have to worry about bikes getting stolen, mopeds are probably going to be safe where you leave them, and people here are able to leave them pretty much everywhere. Movement in the city seems very easy for sure. Side note, anyone here work at or know about Pier 01 down near the water? I just walked by there and was wondering what kind of companies were located there.
- harryh 10y agoWhy would one have to worry about a bike getting stolen but not a moped?
- wccrawford 10y agoOne needs a key to start it up. You can cut a chain to free a bike, but hot-wiring a moped will take longer and be more noticeable.
- jordinl 10y agoyou just need a van an three guys to lift the moped and put it inside the van. It definitely happens in Barcelona https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atJuzEhkRDg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atJuzEhkRDg http://www.lavanguardia.com/local/barcelona/20160802/403624477163/en-barcelona-se-roban-nueve-motos-al-dia-y-se-recuperan-cuatro.html http://www.lavanguardia.com/local/barcelona/20160802/4036244...
- munificent 10y agoBut if you close all the streets to auto traffic, you can't get the van there. Checkmate!
- santialbo 10y agoHere's a nice video explaining what superblocks are http://www.vox.com/2016/8/4/12342806/barcelona-superblocks http://www.vox.com/2016/8/4/12342806/barcelona-superblocks
- westbywest 10y agoI'm surprised the NYT article didn't mention anything about Barcelona's existing legacy in novel and pedestrian-friendly urban layout. The "superilles" likely reference part of the city's existing street grid composed of "illes," where blocks are chamfered to create large intersections and provide space for walkways, green strips, even expand sunlight penetration somewhat. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eixample https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eixample
- pdog 10y ago> Imagine if streets were for strolling, intersections were for playing and cars were almost never allowed. Why is it considered progress to go back to how urban life was several centuries ago? Peter Thiel is right; we used to be optimistic about the future being better than today.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "Why is it considered progress to go back to how urban life was several centuries ago?" Just because something is newer doesn't mean it is automatically better. Regression is just as possible as progression. There's a difference in quality of life between human-focused cities and transport-focused cities. People who have experienced both tend to prefer the former. Why do you think that is?
- macNchz 10y agoWhat would you consider progress, then? To me, this concept of the future sounds better than today. I'm optimistic that people have begun to realize that car-scale cities aren't the only option, and that human-scale neighborhoods can be great places to live. I see this as progress informed by past mistakes (that is, designing cities and neighborhoods around the needs of cars).
- cmyr 10y ago'progress' in the sense of 'changes that occur over time' is distinct from 'progress' in the sense of 'an overall improvement in human quality of life'. When we talk about progress we normally intend the latter case.
- 2AF3 10y agoIf you crave the open road Brasilia welcomes you with open arms
- erjjones 10y agoIndianapolis has a similar hybrid approach to this. http://www.georgiastreetindy.com/ http://www.georgiastreetindy.com/ A street that has pedestrian/event space in the center and one lane roads on the outside. This street connects the Convention Center to the Bankers Life Field House (where the Pacers play).
- maxsilver 10y agoThere's no such thing as a space "just for automobiles". People are in those cars. People who are trying to go to/from somewhere. If you want to get rid of cars, you have to provide some alternative (preferably better) mode of transportation for the people and stuff within them. But that part rarely happens. Everyone loves doing the easy part (ban cars!). No one wants to do the hard part of still letting people and stuff get around somehow. It's like saying "sewers smell gross, we should ban them", while conveniently ignoring the fact that thousands of people are still going to generate wastewater, and it's has to go somewhere.
- pmyjavec 10y agoNo it's not like that at all, cities are for people, freeways are for cars. Delivery trucks and trade people, sure, everyone else should have to park on outskirts and get bus / train / bike in. I bet most planners who let cars into cities had some kind of vested interest in doing so.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoYeah, like not wanting to walk five fucking miles into the city everyday when there's a perfectly usable road.
- jessaustin 10y agoBut that part rarely happens. Everyone loves doing the easy part (ban cars!). Has this happened somewhere, that cars have been banned in an area, and all the businesses have closed since no one could travel there anymore?
- superuser2 10y agoWhat happens is people have to spend more of their free time in transit (and be much less comfortable in transit), or more of their money for housing that is closer to their destinations. This is time and money that is no longer available for the other things people want. The businesses don't close. People cope. Their quality of life just declines. This is sort of necessarily true - people wouldn't be choosing to drive unless they felt it was better than alternatives. Taking away that option is necessarily forcing them into worse alternatives.
- Symmetry 10y agoThey can learn a lot more from Barcelona's $39m/km subway construction costs, compared to something like $1b/km in New York. Some of that is NY's density but worldwide averages are still around $300m/km and Barcelona is a stellar outlier. Also their way of having dedicated bus lanes.
- DominikR 10y agoMost of the cost in infrastructure is actually caused by too many regulations in countries such as the US. It is estimated that current regulations increase the costs by a factor of 6-7. When you look at Barcelona an how they build there it is obvious that they (currently or at least in the recent past) do not have that problem. That's also one of the reasons why the Chinese can complete a large infrastructure project like a skyscraper in a few months while we need half a decade for the same task.
- mikeyouse 10y agoThis is pretty silly since countries like Sweden, France and Germany have much lower infrastructure costs but equally or more stringent regulations and obviously stronger unions. I'd love to see a source for the 6-7x figure for regulation costs. Alon Levy has a good blog that steadily beats the drum about US costs and what can be done to fix them: https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/category/transportation/construction-costs/ https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/category/transp...
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoThe "regulations" are things like like "maybe don't do this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7o8W52NIgXw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7o8W52NIgXw "
- DominikR 10y agoMost of your infrastructure in the US was built during a time when there was comparably little regulation if any at all. Does this mean that everything built back then is built bad? Why does the Empire State Building still stand?
- johnnyforeigner 10y agoI live and work in Poble Nou and I checked out the Superille. It was marvellous. It is (I believe) a temporary project to explore how it all might work. In that sense, it's prototype and that's in fact really cool too. Basically they did an MVP of a Superille - low cost and very fast - in order to validate their hypotheses. They mocked up the place to give people a feel of how living in this way could be. And they spent as little as possible - using old tyres and paint and recycled plywood to mark out spaces and make them feel "owned" by the people. Placing large lots of (quite big) trees and plants in pots on the car-free streets to see how it felt to walk down a street that was leafy and spacious and open. The amount of extra space feels inspiring and liberating. Walking is faster if you want it to be - you can cut across streets and don't need to wait at stop signals. A lot of people riding bikes. A lot of smiles. They definitely could have done a better job explaining it though. I have friends who support the idea but felt they could have been better informed. It felt like they didn't give enough warning. However, what is interesting and cool is that once it was in place they did their best to engage residents in a dialogue about the proposal - they painted markings on the tarmac of the streets to lay out spaces for people to assemble and discuss. They had a soapbox platform for people to rant from, and a bunch of chairs scattered around the street for people to sit and discuss. They had walls for comments to be posted. I certainly hope they go ahead with making it permanent and making more of them. Cities without care are very different and much more humane places to live. Scale matters and cars warp the scale of a city in ways that are counterproductive to vibrant urban life. I'm pretty sure we can overcome the technical issues that restrain us from our inevitable transition away from routine private car use in cities. Problems like what to do about parking are a legacy of the current broken system, not a fact of nature. The economic incentives to car ownership and the infrastructure that supports it are baked into cities right now. But this can change - but not by solving parking but by solving the underlying system and that includes pressuring the system to change through initiatives like this.
- mjevans 10y agoThank you, this is the type of data that I was seeking when I quickly read the article looking for substantive descriptions and data.
- 10y ago
- specialp 10y agoI live in NY and I spent time living in the UK. In the UK most city centers had blocked off pedestrian areas that were only open in the morning for truck deliveries. This was possible because there was a commercial core where people did not reside, and there was plenty of outlying roads to park and drive around. NYC has a LOT of people living in every area of the city. There is a lot of construction and residential deliveries, and emergency traffic. Certain areas have become pedestrian plazas, and some are closed off during the weekend but it is simply not possible to close off a significant amount of space. Anyone driving to Manhattan especially during peak times is not doing it out of convenience as it is extremely inconvenient to drive there. Often people have tools and equipment, and parking in garages in Midtown can easily cost you $40-$60. If you live or are visiting NYC it is a nice thought to have pedestrian only roads. But we have to remember that the trades people that make city life possible really need roads to work.
- chris_7 10y agoWith respect to emergency services, NYC ambulances and fire trucks get stuck in the traffic of private cars/taxis all of the time. If there were less cars, that wouldn't happen. With respect to deliveries, if the sides of streets weren't given away to free parking, delivery vehicles would be free to use loading zones. Most people don't advocate the removal of four-wheeled motor vehicles. They advocate the removal of private cars. (also, superblocks aren't pedestrian-only streets)
- lucozade 10y agoAll these reasons were used in the UK too when pedestrian zones and congestion zones were first touted. For the most part, the envisioned Armageddon didn't occur. In NYC I would expect the biggest problem would be the grid system. Closing off straight roads wouldn't really make a pedestrian nexus which is what makes these work. Turning chunks of downtown pedestrian up to maybe TriBeCa would work fantastically well though.
- Samantha1989 10y agoSeems like a utopia until you factor in the winter climate.
- chris_7 10y agoNew Yorkers don't, like, buy cars in the winter and sell them in the summer. Why would that matter?
- Samantha1989 10y agoCold weather is definitely a consideration when designing outdoor public spaces.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI live in NYC and ... in the winter, on cold days, people just wear heavy coats. It doesn't stop them from doing the things they need to do, like go to work or buy groceries. There's way too many people here for everyone to take cars anyway, regardless of heating requirements. Traffic is already in gridlock conditions for many hours of the day in the summer, so it's not like you could add any trips in the winter for people who don't want to walk. The real solution, although we're starting to go tangential here, is to do what Toronto has done and build a massive city-spanning series of underground pedestrian passages and malls. I've walked through a large part of the system and it is pretty astounding. Here's a map of it: http://www1.toronto.ca/City%20Of%20Toronto/Economic%20Development%20&%20Culture/Tourism%20Services/Files/pdf/PATH-Map.pdf http://www1.toronto.ca/City%20Of%20Toronto/Economic%20Develo...
- notatoad 10y agoor, like other northern cities, build the pedestrian passages one story above road level instead of burying them underground, where the light and windows makes them a much nicer place to be.
- Samantha1989 10y agoI'm from Toronto, that's what informed my original comment. The path is primarily used by commuters with offices in the downtown core. There aren't typically places you would choose to spend prolonged time in - they're often closed on weekends. The idea of 'superblocks' is a great ideal, but needs to be adapted, not duplicated for cold climates. Agree that cities in generally should be much better suited to walking.
- mxuribe 10y agoI wonder if big cities eventually incorporate more of these superblocks, whether the need for rapid transit through some of these areas - as well as accommodating transit for the elderly - will spawn more use of "vehicles" like the Segway [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Segway_PT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Segway_PT]? Maybe not the single-rider segway, but i mean some smaller-scale, non-gas-powered vehicles which allow comfy and safer travel for a few people?
- icebraining 10y agoIn my city, we have these small electric buses[1], designed to travel at a reduced speed. Not exactly tremendously innovative, but still, they're much nicer than regular buses, and since they stop anywhere (just wave), they're helpful for people with reduced mobility. [1] http://www.stopcancerportugal.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/Flexibus.jpg http://www.stopcancerportugal.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03...
- akamaka 10y agoIs there a list or map of all the superblocks that have already been built in Barcelona? I've tried Googling for more info, but all I find are articles praising the urban planning concepts.
- stevoski 10y agoThere exists only one superblock so far, and it is a prototype. It was created last month. The hype is well ahead of the reality. You can find plans for more superblocks, but the official website is mostly in Catalan only, so it might not be too helpful to you (assuming you don't speak Catalan)
- akamaka 10y agoThank you very much for the info! I spent so much time searching in vain for these superblocks, but that was more than a month ago, so now it makes sense.
- parennoob 10y agoAs a relatively infrequent HN user, what is the time limit up to which stories can be re-posted and end up as new stories? I posted this yesterday on HN, and am glad to see some discussion around it. Just curious that the new submission didn't get mapped back to the old one – I've usually get linked back to an already posted article if I repost it after a short time.
- cagataygurturk 10y agoThe first two photos given are from el born and poblenou, which is out of the famous neighborhood l'exiample. Only l'exaimple is famous with their blocks. El born is a part of the historical center of Barcelona but now pedestrian area while poblenou was the industrial area before 1992 olympic games. If you are looking for an example in Barcelona, it should only be l'eixample, which is one of architectural and engineering successes of 20th century. And many times a very big fact is overseen: Barcelona is a village comparing to other big cities of the world. It is famous, popular, a great touristic destination in the summer but in the winter it is a village. A small city where people has normal, calm life. You can't compare it to any metropolitan city.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gonvaled 10y ago> Barcelona is a village comparing to other big cities of the world Compared to what? It has 1.6 million people. Counting metropolitan area, you have nearly 5 million people. And, unfortunately, spanish cities are quite dense (compared to other european cities at least) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barcelona https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barcelona
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoWait, aren't these superblocks doing exactly what all the hip urbanists complain about the suburban culdesacs do?
- Ericson2314 10y agoYour typical American cul-de-sac is completely dead. All buildings are >30 feet from street, and no commercial anything within walking distance.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoThe argument about culdesacs is that they don't allow traffic to flow. They create tiered street systems with feeder roads. "Hip" urbanists are always on about how that's a bad thing. These superblocks do the exact same thing.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The argument about culdesacs is that they don't allow traffic to flow. That's not an "argument" -- that's simply a fact that is what proponents praise them for (keeping neigborhoods quite and safe by keeping out through traffic by providing no access to anywhere traffic would want to go) and what critics criticize them for (preventing efficient transit or foot traffic by lengthening routes to any road that provides access to any place you'd like to go.)
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoSo if that's a bad thing, then why are the self-same urbanists proposing that it's a good thing?
- dragonwriter 10y ago(1) I don't see evidence that its, in general, the same people praising superblocks as criticizing superblocks, and more importantly (2) I don't see evidence that they do the same thing, so even if it is the same people, there's no inherent inconsistency: both reduce local traffic, but by very different means which have different effects. Superblocks don't create a hierarchical network which favors long travel routes but prevents through traffic, superblocks don't create a road system that lacks through access on main corridors within easy walking distant so as to support mass transit, and superblocks don't increase walking/bike travel distance by the manner in which they reduce local motor vehicle traffic.
- xchaotic 10y agoIt's not the first time I read about Barcelona but it is more than just street layout that makes a city tick. It's the people, culture, history, weather, waste and delivery trucks. So you can't just do the exact same thing to other cities and hope that it works.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]