4 ms·
Here's the purported text of the 2002 Belgium law http://www.ethical-perspectives.be/viewpic.php?LAN=E&TABLE=EP&ID=59 FWIW, that law seems eminently reasona
by wahern 10y ago
Here's the purported text of the 2002 Belgium law
http://www.ethical-perspectives.be/viewpic.php?LAN=E&TABLE=EP&ID=59
FWIW, that law seems eminently reasonable to me, and I can't see how extending that to children (esp. given that the parents must agree as well, not just the child and physicians) could constitute cause for concern.
We could quibble over the ethics and morality of euthanasia in the absence of terminal illness. I can't say I have strong feelings one way or another. (Mostly because, IME, when you strip away the context from these sorts of questions there's little of substance remaining to discuss. If I wanted to debate questions of little consequence I'd prefer to write an essay on why smart tabs are the only way to code.)
But if the concern is mental health and people being pressured to kill themselves, it seems to me the law is reasonable. Given that I'm a product of the Western enlightenment and that my preference is to see the law err toward the benefit of individual autonomy, people criticizing constraints in a law permitting euthanasia should be required to proffer data showing that the opposite (status quo) situation--outright ban on euthanasia--in fact results in fewer pressured suicides, assuming the effect exists one way or another. I.e.
If we permit euthanasia, people will be pressured into suicide.
becomes
If we disallow euthanasia, people will not be pressured into suicide.
Show and quantify the latter. Otherwise anti-euthanasia arguments are the equivalent of spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD).
And don't use a strawman. I know of no euthanasia law that doesn't constrain how and when a physician (or other person) can legally provide assistance. No reasonable person (lawmaker or otherwise) needs instruction on dilemmas that mental health and social pressure pose. They're immediately self-evident, and so-called ethicists are wasting ink on the matter as they're no better at resolving the nuances than most other people. The real question is who should get to resolve the situation in thorny cases--people intimately involved in the specific situation, or the state by passing a blanket rule?
- chris_wot 10y agoWell, the logic that if we permit euthanasia then people will be pressured into suicide means that conversely if we disallow euthanasia then people will not be pressured into suicide is a non sequitur. These two implications are not logically equivalent.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wahern 10y agoTrue, they're not equivalent, but the second is implied when we use FUD (intentionally or unintentionally) to bias the status quo. We all have a psychological predisposition to prefer the status quo. And we tend to assume the latter type of statement is true (e.g. believe it intuitive that without legal euthanasia people aren't systematically pressured into suicide) even when we don't explicitly think about it. But if we state the latter explicitly and burden ourselves with it, then it becomes easier to reason about the whole issue. We can examine our biases. Whereas by focusing only on the first statement we're predisposed to believe the status quo better. That's also why I dislike abstract questions and contrived situations (e.g. the Trolley Problem). When we frame social issues too abstractly we lose sight, IMHO, of our inherent biases and implied assumptions, and tend to equivocate outcomes. Stick to real facts as much as possible and it's easier to identify and come to grips with our biases and assumptions. In some ways my opinion is counterintuitive. Isn't it supposed to be the case that by distilling an issue into a simple dilemma that we make it easier to make moral decisions? I don't think so. I think it was Wittgenstein who pointed out, more-or-less, that it's the fine, concrete details of a situation wherein most of the substance lies. By stripping the facts and talking in abstractions or relying on contrived scenarios we've changed the context to an entirely different, fictional reality such that any logical analysis and decision is largely irrelevant to the real-life situation.