7 ms·
The Death Treatment (2015)
- jbob2000 10y agoThe author makes Tom out to be a loving son, but the mother writes a note to him saying that there was a rift between them and he didn't return her love. C'mon Tom, you spend your life ignoring your mother, then she's gone and now you care about her life? This was a bit of a hit-piece on euthanasia, but also a lesson to spend time with your family before the inevitable happens (whether intentional or not).
- pmoriarty 10y ago"you spend your life ignoring your mother, then she's gone and now you care about her life?" Sometime you don't realize what you have until it's gone, as the old saying goes. Besides, whatever emotional or psychological issues existed between this person and his mother, they don't discredit the central points of this article, which were to bring attention to the complexities surrounding the question of euthanasia, to question whether euthanasia is being performed in cases which aren't hopeless after all, and to ask at what point should euthanasia be legally permitted.
- fsloth 10y agoClearly you have no experience of dysfunctional relationships .
- monodeldiablo 10y ago"The author makes Tom out to be a loving son, but the mother writes a note to him saying that there was a rift between them and he didn't return her love. C'mon Tom, you spend your life ignoring your mother, then she's gone and now you care about her life?" An alternative reading of the situation might be that the mother was emotionally needy and manipulative, using her death to get the last word. It's extraordinarily common in teenage suicides, and this woman seemed similarly immature. Anybody with any experience of a dysfunctional relationship could identify the telltale signs of attention-seeking and conditional love. Tom seems very much the victim, here. As does his mother, frankly. It takes a very narrow, cynical view of psychology to claim that her mental state was irreversible, hinting at a serious, systemic lack of oversight and possibly even abuse. The ex post facto notification of the Tom's mother's death is particularly cruel.
- nicolas_t 10y agoI am a proponent of Euthanasia but regulating it in a way that prevents abuse is extremely tricky and I think there should be a lot of transparency for the remaining family who should be informed and have the right to know who made the decision and how the decision was made.
- pmoriarty 10y agoDo you believe there should be any limits placed on legal euthanasia? Such as who can get it or why? Are mentally ill people capable of deciding of what's in their best interests? Children? If children are allowed legal euthanasia, should they be able to decide independent of their parents or guardians? Could their parents or guardians so decide without the child's consent? Should there be any age limit at all?
- nicolas_t 10y agoAs I said. I don't have all the answers. I can see that the system in place in Belgium has some issues and I believe that there while it's important to have legal euthanasia, there's a huge potential of abuses and it's important to find a way to prevent abuses... So, yes, all the questions you ask are really good ones. And, exactly mentally ill people and children are two categories ripe for abuse and where there needs to be tight regulations. It's extremely complex.
- tremon 10y agoAre mentally ill people capable of deciding of what's in their best interests? Children? That's confounding the issue with an orthogonal question. We already have the means to measure and control mental capacity before the law: it's called legal guardianship. If children are allowed legal euthanasia, should they be able to decide independent of their parents or guardians? "Decide" is a bit ambiguous for me. Yes, they should reach their own decision independently; and no, their decision alone is not reason enough to go through with it. Could their parents or guardians so decide without the child's consent? "Without" is a bit ambiguous for me. Yes, if consent cannot be ascertained from the child (e.g. coma, paralysis), that should be possible; and no, "against the child's wishes" should never be allowed. Should there be any age limit at all? I simply don't believe in universal hard limits. There will always be corner cases where what's "right" falls on the wrong side of them. Especially in the case of voluntary termination, I believe that every case is a tragedy in itself, and every case should stand on its own arguments and merits. To do any less would be a disservice to the suffering. Conversely, to put an age limit on voluntary termination to me feels like mandating by law that young people can't suffer (i.e. I think it amounts to using the law to create the illusion of a perfect world).
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoA note on terminology: "euthanasia" is something you do to somebody/something. Euthanize is a transitive verb. You euthanize a pet. I firmly believe in the right of anybody, for any reason, to self-terminate. But that's not euthanasia. When we start getting society involved in the business of terminating people who request it? It's another level of moral and utilitarian complexity. I think a lot of folks are mixing it all together and demanding that my right to self-terminate should force the doctor down the street to help out. These two things do not have to be related. People have been offing themselves for eons. They will continue doing so without the medical establishment. I don't have any easy answers for what society should do for the mentally ill. It seems obvious to me, however, that we should certainly be able to provide food, housing, and medical treatment to them before we'd consider setting up a system to euthanize them.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"I firmly believe in the right of anybody, for any reason, to self-terminate." So if your child was about to jump out a window or run in to a busy street you wouldn't try to stop them?
- paulcole 10y agoIf my adult partner truly wanted to die, I wouldn't stop her but I would encourage her to seek professional advice first and work to find a method that would be foolproof and avoid traumatizing civilian bystanders. So yes, I would stop her from running in front of a car.
- sokoloff 10y agoI would stop my child(ren) from that, but that's because I don't agree that children have that unrestricted right. Even if I did, I might still stop them (or an adult) if I believed their actions were unintentionally putting themselves in harms-way or if they were endangering others (pedestrians below or roadway users).
- ci5er 10y agoIt's interesting that you jump directly to that interpretation. I would have interpreted it to mean that GP believes that the state should not restrict the right of an adult of sound-mind to self-terminate. Given the nature of the state, there would probably be forms and evaluations. Even if I were to agree with GP, I'd probably still stop my friend high on ketamine from walking in front of a bus (if he actually exists, that is).
- pmoriarty 10y agoI used to unequivocally support the right to euthanasia, but as I learned more about it, I realized it was a complex issue, without simple black and white answers. One of the stories that made me reconsider my position was about a young man who was severely burned in an accident which also killed his father. He spent a long time in the burn ward, and was completely disfigured and disabled. He was in constant agony and felt he had nothing to live for. He made a video about himself called "Let Me Die", and submitted it to his state's legislature, begging them to allow him to legally end his own life. His appeal was denied, his injuries eventually healed (to the extent that he was no longer in the burn ward, not completely), he was glad that he lived, and went on to a career of educating others about these issues. Another story that affected me was about some island where the population discovered a readily available fruit that grew on trees on the island was deadly. So they had a rash of suicides, with teenagers killing themselves because they were told by their parents to clean their rooms or some such. I may be confusing bits of that last story with some others that I've read. But I have read multiple stories of teenagers killing themselves over things that most mature adults consider trivial and blown out of proportion by teenage angst that the kids would most likely would have been able to put behind them as they got older, if only they hadn't killed themselves. There are legitimate concerns about autonomy, self-determination, and paternalism. I'm the first to admit those are serious concerns, and in some extreme cases the decision to allow or even help someone take their own life is clearly ethical. But there are also a lot of cases where the ethics of the situation are not so clear-cut, and I find it disturbing that some people are so dogmatic about their position that they can't see any dillema, are unwilling to seek other ways of helping or alleviating these people's suffering, and seem to view suicide as the default answer to difficult situations. I'm also disturbed to hear that Etienne Vermeersch, a philosopher of ethics and "the most influential intellectual in Flanders", can confidently proclaim that Belgium "stands, ethically, at the top of the world." This smacks of hubris, and is unworthy of a man or nation so distinguished.
- wahern 10y agoHere's the purported text of the 2002 Belgium law http://www.ethical-perspectives.be/viewpic.php?LAN=E&TABLE=EP&ID=59 FWIW, that law seems eminently reasonable to me, and I can't see how extending that to children (esp. given that the parents must agree as well, not just the child and physicians) could constitute cause for concern. We could quibble over the ethics and morality of euthanasia in the absence of terminal illness. I can't say I have strong feelings one way or another. (Mostly because, IME, when you strip away the context from these sorts of questions there's little of substance remaining to discuss. If I wanted to debate questions of little consequence I'd prefer to write an essay on why smart tabs are the only way to code.) But if the concern is mental health and people being pressured to kill themselves, it seems to me the law is reasonable. Given that I'm a product of the Western enlightenment and that my preference is to see the law err toward the benefit of individual autonomy, people criticizing constraints in a law permitting euthanasia should be required to proffer data showing that the opposite (status quo) situation--outright ban on euthanasia--in fact results in fewer pressured suicides, assuming the effect exists one way or another. I.e. If we permit euthanasia, people will be pressured into suicide. becomes If we disallow euthanasia, people will not be pressured into suicide. Show and quantify the latter. Otherwise anti-euthanasia arguments are the equivalent of spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD). And don't use a strawman. I know of no euthanasia law that doesn't constrain how and when a physician (or other person) can legally provide assistance. No reasonable person (lawmaker or otherwise) needs instruction on dilemmas that mental health and social pressure pose. They're immediately self-evident, and so-called ethicists are wasting ink on the matter as they're no better at resolving the nuances than most other people. The real question is who should get to resolve the situation in thorny cases--people intimately involved in the specific situation, or the state by passing a blanket rule?
- wtbob 10y ago> “Who am I to convince patients that they have to suffer longer than they want?” One wonders who he is to convince them that they may end their suffering. I think that there's something very cold about a society which says, 'on net, the world is better without you in it' not to someone who is a murderer, rapist or traitor but to someone who is depressed or afflicted with cancer. > Last year, De Standaard, a prominent Flemish newspaper, published a long tribute to a depressed mother who was euthanized after being abandoned by her boyfriend and becoming disillusioned by her psychiatric care. “I am forever grateful to her that she handled this so well,” her twenty-four-year-old son told the paper. “I am so glad we were able to say goodbye in a beautiful way.” One wonders if the son attempted to support his mother in life, rather than tell her goodbye. > On the morning on which the euthanasia was scheduled, Boeykens’s daughter, Kerstin, said that she called De Deyn, crying, and begged him to move her mother’s 9 A.M. appointment a few hours later, so that she would have time to drop her children off at school and then drive to the clinic. But De Deyn said that he was booked for the rest of the day. (De Deyn denies that this happened.) Records show that Boeykens died at 9:20 A.M., at which point De Deyn removed her brain and performed an autopsy. I don't really know if there's anything more to add to this vignette. It's like something out of Brave New World (a book which, incidentally, I've always found far more prophetic than 1984).
- ubernostrum 10y agoYour whole comment is kinda coming across as searching for the worst possible interpretations of statements so you can attack the person delivering them and hope it'll rub off on the argument. Maybe don't do that? One wonders if the son attempted to support his mother in life, rather than tell her goodbye. Also: when my mother was diagnosed with (terminal) cancer, she tried the treatments at first. Chemo, radiation, everything. Doctors told her at best it might buy her a few more months. After learning what those treatments would do to her, she made the decision that a few months of that wasn't worth it, and stopped treatment. Do you think it was my job as a son to try to force her to continue, out of "support" for her?
- wtbob 10y ago> Do you think it was my job as a son to try to force her to continue, out of "support" for her? No; there's a major difference between refusing further treatment and pursuing suicide.
- MichaelMoser123 10y agoOld and dependent people might be pressured by their families into agreeing to euthanasia. After reading this article i think that they don't have enough safeguards that could prevent such a scenario from happening. I have come to think that any framework that allows for euthanasia is creating the possibility of abuse in similar situations. The physician in the article kept referring to the free will of the patient; now Free will in personal matters is not an absolute entity, in practice it may quite often be limited/influenced/determined by ones environment.
- eth0up 10y agoTerry Pratchett made a very interesting documentary on the subject, titled: Choosing to Die. Here's a link to the documentary: http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xnu340_terry-pratchett-choosing-to-die_shortfilms http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xnu340_terry-pratchett-choo... - while it lasts, I guess. It covers the Dignitas[1] facility in Switzerland, which specializes in euthanasia (eu = good & thanatos = death), mostly for the wealthy ... if I remember correctly. It's one heck of a subject and the above documentary really hit me quite hard. For those interested in the subject (hopefully not the action), you might also find Exit International[2] pretty intriguing. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dignitas_%28Swiss_non-profit_organisation%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dignitas_%28Swiss_non-profit_o... 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit_International https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit_International
- hexane360 10y agoI'm going to have to start using the word "dysthanasia" as a euphemism more often. (dysphemism?)
- eth0up 10y agoWell, just avoid "Disthanasia", as I just learned of an actual Dis, which might be confused with Orcus, some deity of the underworld. I play linguist and get pushed down a Greek rabbit hole...
- woliveirajr 10y agoFew days ago I went through some surgery. During the recover I didn't get all the drugs I was supposed to. Then I learnt what pain is. How much pain you can feel if you don't have your dose of morphine. It made me think a lot. I knew my pain would go away, there were drugs for it, etc. But and those who are suffering a great pain, with no drug making effect to reduce it, and knowing that the time is coming? It's not humane not to provide an end for those who want it, those who are suffering and the end is near. It was not my case. But I'm sure it's the case of someone else.
- Ataraxic 10y agoI tend to support euthanasia, but its practice in that article scares me. I guess I believe that people ultimately do have a responsibility to others. Her son did not ask to be born and Tom's quote "You’ve just taken away the suffering of one person and transposed it to another!" convinces me that euthanasia is not as clean as we might believe. What if Tom having suffered this triggering event and having a genetic predisposition to depression applies for euthanasia? It seems euthanasia for the whole family is ethically above board in Belgium, but I still feel that outcome is unacceptable. The only thing that really bothers me is that so many ethicists in Belgium (as far as this article describes) believe this is clear cut. I generally don't have too many disagreements with most concepts of western philosophy, but if this is the end result of the application of self-determination, I definitely have plenty of reservations. Finding out that your parent committed suicide after the fact is just unacceptable to me, especially because the parent in this article did honestly express to the doctor that she cares for them.
- tremon 10y agoI'm not sure that I agree with your belief that voluntary termination (I prefer that term over euthanasia) can ever be clean. It is a process that is necessarily fraught with pain, even if that pain isn't visible on the outside. I'd like to believe that no doctor would take such a decision lightly, but that of course is hard to ascertain. I do agree with your sentiment about the ethicists. The article paints a picture like the review boards and experts are closing ranks against the "outside world". It's somewhat understandable given that these are considered hard-won "victories" by the humanist camp and still under constant pressure, but it reduces transparency in an area that absolutely requires both transparency and accountability. It's almost like regulatory capture: it encourages practitioners to play it fast and loose knowing they will be backed, and that should not be allowed. However, in this particularly case: I understand it can be very hard for next-of-kin to learn that someone close has chosen to die, and that they were not involved in the process. I've watched it happen twice from somewhat nearby, and I certainly hope never to experience it any closer. The anger, hurt and guilt from not being included in such a life-altering decision can be enormous. At the same time, I don't see how drawing more people into the situation should be up to the physician; that choice too should be squarely in the patient's hands. For me it is enough that the doctor suggested she should contact her children. For me, the bigger question is why these doctors felt qualified to assess her wish: it does not sound like any of the doctors that approved her request had more than a cursory involvement in her (long-term) treatment.
- reitanqild 10y agoI have read about parents begging for euthanasia before I think - in notes about poster parents of the nazi empire or something.