25 ms·
Just yesterday I was thinking how all of the platforms are still using vfat as a go between. There really should be a new FS "for them all"
by ianai 10y ago
Just yesterday I was thinking how all of the platforms are still using vfat as a go between. There really should be a new FS "for them all"
- nathancahill 10y agohttps://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- DigitalJack 10y agoPretty soon, we'll just use XKCD numbers and not bother linking. We'll just call something or other "hey, that's a 927"
- Sophistifunk 10y agoWe should create a URI standard for that; xkcd://927
- rndgermandude 10y agoLet me propose the xkcd2 scheme, to be used like xkcd2:927, because who really needs those two slashes?!
- tychuz 10y agoMy proposal: xkcd3, works as xkcd3:927 AND xkcd3://927 And that's why Linux desktop is going nowhere.
- jepler 10y agohi, what about xkcd4:ⅽⅿⅹⅹⅶⅹ or xkcd5:٩٢٧ (note: may not appear in correct reading order due to technical limitations)
- Razengan 10y agoI propose a browser powered by deep machine learning that lets you just write 927 and automatically figures out that it refers to an XKCD by inferring the context from looking at the content on the rest of the page.
- chungy 10y agoShould be simple enough: https://github.com/chungy/xkcd-uri https://github.com/chungy/xkcd-uri
- ChoHag 10y ago> Just made for fun, not expected to see any wide use. Well that's jinxed it.
- sdrothrock 10y agoEchoes of "Shaka, when the walls fell."
- stonogo 10y agoAll attempts at such will fail. vfat won because it works in Windows without additional drivers. Anything you come up with to replace it will also have to work in Windows without additional drivers. It will also have have a workable implementation in what is essentially equivalent to the public domain, and be simple enough to process that hardware manufacturers can read it with a microcontroller. I would love to see it happen, but I am not optimistic.
- duaneb 10y agovfat only won in the sense that if you're forced to use windows you still have to use vfat. In every other context there is a better option. I haven't needed to move files to a windows box in 15 years so—to me—it's a massive surprise anyone still uses it at all. Just don't use USB keys; they're terrible security-wise and you're forced to use technology built for your grandmother.
- stonogo 10y agoThat is the only sense in which a 'universal file system' can win. There is no other context. Your personal usage habits are completely irrelevant ("I haven't had to shoot a gun since the first gulf war, so to me it's a massive surprise that anyone still fights wars at all.") I don't use USB keys. I don't have any windows systems. But I do have UEFI, and that is based on FAT as well. Disregarding my grandmother's technical prowess, this technology is here to stay, and sticking your head in the sand about it doesn't advance any causes.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Aloha 10y agoYou're an outlier. I live in an environment where I need to move files between several builds of Windows, Linux and macOS - and often where there is no network access because of security policy (misguided policy perhaps). Thumb Drives are the only way to function.
- wmf 10y agoYou could call it a universal disk format. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Disk_Format https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Disk_Format
- RayDonnelly 10y agoI tried UDF for a few months on a macOS/Linux/Windows triple boot. It doesn't work reliably enough. I've switched to ext2 using e2fsd and Paragon (which I paid for) on Windows and macOS respectively. Fingers crossed. I wish someone would port F2FS to Windows and macOS. This could be a good starting point for macOS.
- ianai 10y agoWhat sort of issues did you have with udf?
- RayDonnelly 10y agoWindows threw up CRC errors. I am not blaming Windows here, that would be unfair. Perhaps it was the only one that checked CRCs on read and one of the others didn't write CRCs on write. My use case was to store many large git repo clones and MP3s.
- djsumdog 10y agoI think today it's exFat instead of vfat. That seems to be supported by a lot of phones and devices for large storage.
- wruza 10y agoexFAT suddenly dirty-dismounts both on windows and osx, and is hard to mount again for regular user. Tried it as common r/w storage for bootcamp -- complete trash, cannot be used for long-connected drives, hyperactive torrents, big files. Copying some files forth-back is okay though.
- loeg 10y agoNo, exFat is patent encumbered and isn't as simple and well documented as vfat (so non-Windows implementations are worse). vfat is still the common denominator. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExFAT#Restrictive_licensing_and_software_patents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ExFAT#Restrictive_licensing_an...
- hobarrera 10y agoFar from being "simple to implement", it's patent encumbered, making implementations for many OSs highly unlikely.
- tracker1 10y agovia fuse, ntfs is pretty broadly available... iirc there was a recent post about efforts to bring a fuse alternative for windows in (which should bring ext3 and btrfs)... I tend to just use ntfs for most of my external storage and cifs for network storage only because it's easier to get on my non-windows systems than nfs and ext3 are to get working on windows... ymmv though.
- dom0 10y ago> about efforts to bring a fuse alternative for windows in You mean dokany? 'cause that one is one quite stable project.