7 ms·
I admire the author's selflessness. At the same time, it seemed easier to be selfless as a teenager, probably for similar reasons for why it's easier to draft 1
by danso 10y ago
I admire the author's selflessness. At the same time, it seemed easier to be selfless as a teenager, probably for similar reasons for why it's easier to draft 18-year-olds than it is 28-year-olds. Given young persons willingness to sacrifice for the greater cause without realizing that life extends well past your 30s and 40s, I wonder if more shouldn't be done to let young donors think of the risks, so that their naïveté isn't something that the system takes advantage of.
The author's right to ask for better data and tracking of donors. That said, his current worries are likely to be heavily informed by selection bias:
> Five years after the surgery, when I was 23 and getting ready to go to medical school, I began working in a research lab that was looking at kidney donors who had gone on to develop kidney failure. For that research, I talked to more than 100 such donors. In some cases, the remaining kidneys failed; in others, the organ became injured or developed cancer. The more I learned, the more nervous I became about the logic of my decision at age 18 to donate.
If you spend a lot of time talking only to donors where things have gone wrong, yeah, you'll be paranoid. Reminds me of being a cops reporter in which you strongly associate certain neighborhoods with shootings and murders because, professionally, those incidents are the only times you ever visit those neighborhoods.
- criley2 10y ago>At the same time, it seemed easier to be selfless as a teenager, probably for similar reasons for why it's easier to draft 18-year-olds than it is 28-year-olds. Given young persons willingness to sacrifice for the greater cause without realizing that life extends well past your 30s and 40s I totally agree, the biological basis of this is Pre-frontal Cortex development. "The [prefrontal cortex] isn't fully developed and won't be until the person is 25 years old or so." https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?ContentTypeID=1&ContentID=3051 https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?Con... "This brain region has been implicated in planning complex cognitive behavior, personality expression, decision making, and moderating social behaviour. The basic activity of this brain region is considered to be orchestration of thoughts and actions in accordance with internal goals." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prefrontal_cortex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prefrontal_cortex I can't understand any other context for drafting 18 year olds other than taking advantage of their youth and incomplete development, but avoiding Presentism and the comfort of Mutually Assured Destruction / Pax Americana, I can understand why when the cards are on the table and your entire society is at risk, why you must call all hands, young and old, into Total War a la WW1 or WW2. As far as donations go, that's got to be a morally gray area as well for all the reasons you mention.
- linkregister 10y ago> I can't understand any other context for drafting 18 year olds other than taking advantage of their youth and incomplete development 18-year-olds have been volunteer recruited and drafted for perhaps the entire history of organized armies. Child soldiers also have (and in some countries still are) enlisted also. I suspect this is only out of extreme necessity, as the moral and practical drawbacks are overwhelming. When the United States has instituted the draft, it has encompassed 18-to-45 year-olds for immediate enlistment. 18-25 year-olds comprise the largest age group of new volunteer enlistees in the US. The largest barriers to military service qualification are health reasons and family situations. It would follow that younger enlistees would have lower likelihood of physical injuries and being the sole caretaker of a dependent. Your post made sense until your bizarre digression to armed service being linked to incomplete prefrontal cortex development. It can be appealing to find sinister motivations behind institutions you dislike, but there isn't a basis in fact here. The explanation is tradition, health, and lack of obligations.
- M_Grey 10y agoIt's hardly bizarre, but it's not put in terms of cortical development either. It is however a bit of, "Give me a girl at an impressionable age, and she will be mine for life." Ignoring that reality, and why 12 year olds are more likely to pick up a machete than a 30 year old, is what's bizarre.
- linkregister 10y agoIs it true that 12 year olds are more likely to pick up a machete than 30 year olds?
- M_Grey 10y agoIn a general context, or in the context of what we're talking about here? In general, I don't know, in context... yes. You can get most kids on board with almost anything, and those you can't, you can generally abuse or otherwise force to submit. They're not set in their ways, they don't have as clear a sense of the world, and their impulse control usually stinks. There's a reason that everyone, for better or worse, wants to get to kids early, and often. Advertisers, religions, people trying to teach kids how to deal with advertisers and religions, militaries, etc... all see the value in "getting them young."
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI've considered offering to be a kidney donor. Now that I have a kid, I'm glad I didn't - what if my kid needs it? What if my wife does?
- nothrabannosir 10y agoDo you not get a "+1" for anyone of your choosing at any point in time if you donated to a stranger in the past?
- chrisseaton 10y agoHow could they guarantee that? What if you need to call that right in and they can't find anyone compatible?
- nothrabannosir 10y agoThere's kidneys, just not for you if you're at the bottom of the list. Compare to kidney exchange (http://transplants.ucla.edu/site.cfm?id=112 http://transplants.ucla.edu/site.cfm?id=112): if your friend or spouse needs one, but you're incompatible, you can find another pair who has the inverse compatibility problem and swap with them. Or more, and form a chain (e.g. this 35-kidney chain: http://abc27.com/2015/03/30/paired-exchange-record-70-people-35-kidneys/ http://abc27.com/2015/03/30/paired-exchange-record-70-people...). What I was referring to is Good Samaritan donation: Many Good Samaritan donors choose to start chains because it is a way to help more than one person suffering from kidney failure. One chain typically facilitates anywhere from 2 to 30 transplants. The NKR pays for donation insurance for all Good Samaritan donor who start chains through NKR. http://www.kidneyregistry.org/living_donors.php?cookie=1 http://www.kidneyregistry.org/living_donors.php?cookie=1 EDIT: Ah, found it---they're called Kidney Vouchers :) http://transplants.ucla.edu/site.cfm?id=406 http://transplants.ucla.edu/site.cfm?id=406 great name. Although limited to one predetermined person, so not exactly a blanket "+1".
- pavel_lishin 10y agoIt still seems like it's an exchange, just not an immediate one. Still, all of those things are excellent ideas.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoAre shootings and murder common in all neighborhoods? Isn't it correct to strongly associate a neighborhood with shootings and murder if you are repeatedly visiting the neighborhood due to a shooting and/or murder?
- danso 10y agoYou can say that a neighborhood has more shootings/murders than other neighborhoods. What I'm talking about is the phenomenon of thinking of that neighborhood just in terms of those incidents, because that's all you ever hear about them. You aren't there for the 99.9% of the time when things are mundane.
- ellyagg 10y agoYes, despite that you are grayed at this point, that example is not logically the same as the phenomenon under discussion. If you talk to a lot of people with kidney failure you might conclude kidney failure is more likely than it is. This makes no sense as you are specifically looking for people with kidney failure, but humans aren't great at perspective here. If you are looking for murder victims and a separate attribute--where these murders take place--is clearly correlated with murder victims, it is correct to notice that correlation.
- plan6 10y ago> I admire the author's selflessness. But if he is publicly regretting donating a kidney, won't he be preventing many kidneys from being donated? I just don't him going public with his opinion as a good thing. It may become something he regrets even more than his kidney donation. Even the reporter and the post's title is irresponsible. If I were just reading through the headlines, it would influence my feelings about donating a kidney. Instead, the title could have been "Kidney-donating doc pleads: please register as an organ donor" and have similar content in the post, but with the main point being that people should register to be an organ donor if they die.
- kelnos 10y agoMaybe it should influence you. From what it sounds like, he was essentially misled as to how unlikely it is that he could suffer complications down the road. If you (or anyone else) is less likely to donate because of that, perhaps that's a good thing. Not good for the potential recipient, perhaps, but good for you, which is just as important.