4 ms·
Seat belts were offered in cars prior to regulation [1]: "American car manufacturers Nash (in 1949) and Ford (in 1955) offered seat belts as options, while Swe
by jerf 10y ago
Seat belts were offered in cars prior to regulation [1]:
"American car manufacturers Nash (in 1949) and Ford (in 1955) offered seat belts as options, while Swedish Saab first introduced seat belts as standard in 1958.[7] After the Saab GT 750 was introduced at the New York Motor Show in 1958 with safety belts fitted as standard, the practice became commonplace.[8]"
"... The world's first seat belt law was put in place in 1970, in the state of Victoria, Australia, making the wearing of a seat belt compulsory for drivers and front-seat passengers. This legislation was enacted after trialing Hemco seatbelts, designed by Desmond Hemphill (1926–2001), in the front seats of police vehicles, lowering the incidence of officer injury and death."
Wikipedia mentions "in 1959, Congress passed legislation requiring all automobiles to comply with certain safety standards." but the writing leaves it unclear to me whether that included mandating seat belts.
The theory that government regulation is mandatory or companies will never do anything healthy requires a consumer base who assigns no regard to their health and safety, which is obviously false. I'm not say it's all market, either; I think a government that watches a free market but does not participate is generally the ideal. But the idea that we wouldn't have standard seat belts if it weren't for government is silly.
In the general case, the government can't mandate things that don't exist yet. They can at least prod things in certain directions with things like CAFE standards, but that's all.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seat_belt#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seat_belt#History
- vertex-four 10y ago> The theory that government regulation is mandatory or companies will never do anything healthy requires a consumer base who assigns no regard to their health and safety, which is obviously false. Either that or companies price health-and-safety options out of the price range of some consumers, resulting in a society where we think it's right that anyone under a certain level of income doesn't deserve to be as safe as we are. At least in the current system, you can't buy things without much the same level of safety as we have - meaning that you can't realistically push their income+benefits any lower without lots of pushback. If we thought that health and safety features were optional... that'd be a lot different.
- witty_username 10y ago> resulting in a society where we think it's right that anyone under a certain level of income doesn't deserve to be as safe as we are. This sounds bad, but even current society is like this. You can always use more money to be more safe. Car regulations don't change this but they do make cars less affordable.
- vertex-four 10y ago> You can always use more money to be more safe. To some degree, and for some things. In general, spending more on your car isn't going to help much when you get into a crash.
- witty_username 10y agoYou can buy more safety systems, like ABS. You could buy a car with a larger crumple zone. You can drive more slowly, which would cost you time which is ultimately money.
- talmand 10y agoDepends, there are a level of technologies on cars based around accidents that require more money to obtain. Small, cheap car that meets bare minimum safety regulations versus big, expensive car that goes beyond required safety regulations. I bet the survivability rate of a Tesla is much higher than my Altima in the same near-fatal accident.
- ashark 10y agoI think an under-appreciated effect of regulation is making participation in the market easier. I don't need to research the apple I'm buying at the store. I don't need to look into the company that certified its safety to ensure it's not captured by the very company producing/selling the apple, or that it's not the same company that had huge scandal last year but with a new name (to take the Anarcho-Libertarian idea that private companies would replace government regulators in certifying safety and quality). That huge time/money cost is just gone. Anything in the grocery store will be basically fine. I can just toss it in the cart without a thought. I might gain some benefit from researching the products there, but it will be marginal. I don't have to do that stuff to just probably not die of food poisoning. Same with car safety and any number of other things. Regulation ensures a baseline under which products will (generally) not drop, making it easier (cheaper) for buyers to spend. It reduces (consumer) overhead and greases wheels.
- gwright 10y ago> the general case, the government can't mandate things that don't exist yet. You would think that would be true, but ... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/10/business/energy-environment/companies-face-fines-for-not-using-unavailable-biofuel.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/10/business/energy-environmen...