2 ms·
I hear the "government hiring private contractors" argument often as a compromise between complete free market economics and public utilities. The argument fal
by chatmasta 10y ago
I hear the "government hiring private contractors" argument often as a compromise between complete free market economics and public utilities.
The argument falls apart when there exists effectively no competition between contractors. At thiat point, the government may even end up paying more for its favorite contractor (whether by choice or lock-in) than it would if it managed its own staff.
The advantage of privatization is supposedly efficiency. Private companies must be efficient in order to survive, in large part because if a private company is not efficient, a competitor will be. Therefore, in order to capture this efficiency advantage, there must exist at least two private competitors for every government contract.
I'd be interested to hear of solutions that prioritize competition between private contractors, rather than encouraging nepotism or cronyism in the procurement process. Otherwise, you're just replacing the public monopoly with a private one, losing any gains from what should be the chief advantage of privatization: a competitive market.