4 ms·
These are examples of monopolies, and not free market. I think, and it's my opinion: If you make something private in a free market, it's always good for qualit
by csomar 10y ago
These are examples of monopolies, and not free market. I think, and it's my opinion: If you make something private in a free market, it's always good for quality and prices.
There are two possibilities that can make this promise false:
1. The market is not free. For example, a metro subway. It's a monopoly. You can't have 6 subway lines and you pick one of them.
2. The market was heavily financed by tax payers money. For example, a bus route that it is not profitable but still running for the benefit of the few poor people using it. This can happen in a government situation but not in a private situation.
- rubidium 10y agoArticle discusses inequality, not quality and prices. In a free market, quality and prices will (eventually) optimize for what the market can sustain. What the market can sustain may be _very_ unequal for the rich and poor in the market.
- djschnei 10y agoKind of an interesting problem, no? It's a question between what things we want to economize and the things we don't want to economize. In the long run, however, I fail to see how we really have a choice. Since "public" services are tied to some pretty basic realities; they still rely on human labor and they still rely on finite resources. So the real question is - do we want to realize the inherent inequality of existence now or push the ball down the road and assume (usually on behalf of future generations) the inherent inefficiencies of public work? For me, I find it troublesome to take out credit cards in my children's names and hope for the best... I'd rather accept the realities of resource allocation now and maximize the system's efficiency. And sure, that might expose us to inequalities; I, for one, am super psyched for a post-scarcity economy :)
- jellicle 10y agoYou're using "free market" when you mean "competitive market". There are very many free markets that are not competitive. The primary goal of companies selling a good or service is to reduce competition to minimal levels, as that allows maximal profits.
- djschnei 10y agoI think that analysis of free market stimuli proves an inherently flawed understanding of the free market. In reality, there is not a single free market industry that is protected from disruption. The very possibility of disruption is a competitive stimuli. The ONLY circumstances of non-competitive marketplaces occur with coercive enforcement; this includes things like organized crime controlled black markets and government protected/orchestrated industries. https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/personal-incredulity https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/personal-incredulity
- jrockway 10y ago> 1. The market is not free. For example, a metro subway. It's a monopoly. You can't have 6 subway lines and you pick one of them. New York City had three subway companies until the 1940s and the city took them over (one was already owned by the city). Tokyo has two metros and a large number of independent railroads (one metro is owned by the city; one railroad was owned by the government until the late 80s).
- bryondowd 10y agoWere these companies actually competing, or just operating separate but likely connected routes? In other words, if you need to go from specific place A to specific place B, what are the odds you could choose which company to use. If location rather than choice dictate which service you use, it is essentially the same as what we have with cable companies. Each company has a monopoly in the zones they operate, and can charge whatever the consumers will bear without worrying about being undercut by competition, because a competitor would need to build significant infrastructure at which point the original company would just lower prices and the competitor would be unable to recover their costs. It makes sense that infrastructure like this should be publicly owned, even if operation is contracted privately.
- jrockway 10y agoBoth. Sometimes the routes compete, sometimes they're complementary. In New York, look at the IND Concourse Line and IRT Jerome Avenue Line, they're 2-4 blocks apart for the entire route. Meanwhile, much of the city has no subway service at all. More nefariously, the IND built a totally-unnecessary lower-level platform at 42nd St./8th Ave. to block the IRT's extension of the Flushing line. Indeed, when this line was finally extended a few years ago, cost was added by having to demolish this superfluous station! (Who knew that the city would eventually own both.) In Tokyo, the Tokyo metro Fukutoshin Line basically exists to compete with JR's Yamanote Line for people traveling between Ikebukuro/Shinjuku/Shibuya. Sure, now there's a one-seat-ride between Shinrinkouen and Yokohama... but does anyone do that except to post videos on YouTube? I doubt it. Eliminating a transfer probably wasn't worth the billions of yen spent to build a new subway line. These are the most egregious duplications I can think of, but some are more subtle. I can take the IND or IRT from home to work in the exact same amount of time, depending on whether I want to walk one block in Manhattan or the same distance in Brooklyn. When I lived in Tokyo, we would go out of our way to avoid paying the higher Toei fare when Metro would suffice. (It was called "Eidan" then though!)
- mason240 10y ago>For example, a bus route that it is not profitable but still running for the benefit of the few poor people using it. This can happen in a government situation but not in a private situation. It is if running that route is part of the contract.
- usgroup 10y agoI think surprisingly many services and products do not fit this paradigm. Recall that in a free market, no company nor buyer is a price setter. Price is determined in aggregate only.