4 ms·
This article is terrible. Sure you can find examples of privatization having less than stellar results. But it's not uniformly so and I doubt it's even commonly
by koolba 10y ago
This article is terrible. Sure you can find examples of privatization having less than stellar results. But it's not uniformly so and I doubt it's even commonly so.
> The report, “How Privatization Increases Inequality,” is full of such examples. There’s the transit system of Nassau County, New York, privatized in 2012 in an effort to cut costs. Almost immediately after Veolia signed a contract with the city, the company reduced service on 30 routes, and eliminated several lines all together. A year later, fares increased. They’ve gone up every year since. More lines have been eliminated, and still the transit system continues to face budget shortfalls.
If they care so much about which lines are operated, that should be part of the contract. Why would the company continue to operate lines that would be running at a loss? Sounds like the residents should be complaining about whoever negotiated this terrible contract (i.e. whoever was wined and dined into signing it).
> Oftentimes, it’s worker’s wages, which worsens income inequality. Government jobs used to offer healthy salary and benefit packages, making them steady careers that could stabilize communities, the report notes. But privatized positions for the same work often offer lower wages, reduced benefits and little to no retirement security.
Who's going to pay those healthy salaries and pensions? If the latter are just unfunded mandates, it's hardly fair to compare them against a private company that has to cover it's obligations as they come in, via defined contribution plans or into a sinking fund, based on the money it's actually collecting (v.s. future higher taxes).
- Retric 10y agoThe basic privatization question is this: Service was not producing a profit, it will be. Where exactly is that money coming from?
- merpnderp 10y agoHistorically it's from improved efficiencies, which privitazation incentivizes and government does not.
- rayiner 10y agoGovernment inefficiency mostly comes from above market wages and benefits to lower-skill workers and money-losing routes and services. If you can't touch either, you're pretty stuck. E.g., how would a real private corporation run say Amtrak more efficiently that didn't involve cutting jobs and unprofitable routes?
- merpnderp 10y agoIt wouldn't because most of the routes aren't economical at the current consumer price. Amtrak always feels like the entire country subsidizing the rich and powerful as they commute over the NE.
- harryh 10y agoAmtrak always feels like the entire country subsidizing the rich and powerful as they commute over the NE. It's actually the opposite. The corridor from Washington DC to NYC to Boston is basically the only profitable Amtrak route and subsidizes the rest of the country. See https://www.brookings.edu/interactives/u-s-passenger-rail-ridership/ https://www.brookings.edu/interactives/u-s-passenger-rail-ri...
- chrisseaton 10y agoDo rich and powerful people take Amtrak trains? I would have thought they would fly.
- Retric 10y agoIn cases like Medicare, which has lower overhead than private insurance, it's a tricky question.
- pdabbadabba 10y agoThat's certainly the party line, but is there any evidence that it's actually true? I've seen little to support it, especially when you disregard "efficiency" gains that come from cutting what a municipal agency would have called "services." The problem, as many others are also pointing out, is that government entities and private businesses typically have (and often should have different motivations). So when a private business takes over and makes things more efficient, this often comes at the expense of things that we want our government to value, not economize on.
- merpnderp 10y agoThen the municipality should have made that service a required part of the contract with penalties built in. The government always sets the rules of the economy, which is why it tends towards monopolies where graft and corruption can flourish. The ultimate example being when the government controls everything and you get the absurd differences between near sides of the Iron Curtain.
- djschnei 10y agoInteresting case. Isn't it true, however, that everything is economized whether we like it or not? Even public works that add "value" still rely on finite resources (human labor, natural resources, etc...). Can we really just ignore the laws of resource allocation because we "value" something? If we really "valued" something, why not let the market strike the balance between value and efficiency?
- Retric 10y agoExternalities, generally prevent profit from aligning with optimum resource allocation for society. I may only be willing to pay X to ride a subway and it might cost Y to provide subway service, but having one less commuter on the roads is worth Z to society. In a classic free market if X < Y then I don't ride the subway, but if X < (Y - Z) society is better off if I do ride the subway. Further, subways systems, electricity, water, etc are far more efficient as a single provider which suggests a heavily regulated utility. But, if the government is going to subsidizes and heavily regulate a company like this then it's not really a company any more just a government organization with a funky org chart. To further complicate things, this opens the door for a huge range of corruption as someone is legally allowed to take taxpayer money and profit.
- chatmasta 10y agoOne interesting example of pensions hurting public enterprise is the USPS. IIRC, the government mandated that the USPS guarantee pensions for 70 years, meaning they literally have to have enough cash on hand to guarantee pensions even in the case of total organizational collapse. Requirements like this render it impossible for government services to profitably compete with private enterprises unencumbered by such stipulations. This results in zombie public organizations operating indefinitely at a loss in order to subsidize the wages and livelihood of employees. Sure, maybe the employees are better off and therefore "inequality is reduced," but this is a misdirection. The loss needs to be absorbed economically somehow, and in many cases its the taxpayers who foot the bill. Even worse, often "the bill" will not arrive until decades later, in the form of a massive deficit compounded by years of interest rates requiring future tax hikes.