3 ms·
Your previous comment certainly appeared to misunderstand dual criminality since you thought it was relevant whether or not Lauri had been convicted of a crime
by foldr 10y ago
Your previous comment certainly appeared to misunderstand dual criminality since you thought it was relevant whether or not Lauri had been convicted of a crime in the UK. Clearly, however, that is not relevant to the satisfaction of the dual criminality requirement, which is the requirement that the offence for which the person is being extradited is also an offence in the country they're being extradited from.
With regard to your Iceland example, I doubt that Iceland and Sudan have an extradition treaty. If they do, I don't see in principle why someone who lived in Iceland but was involved in producing pornography in Sudan should not be extradited for it. In practice, however, the probable lack of an extradition treaty, and the probable flaws in the Sudanese justice system, would make it very unlikely that an Icelandic court would approve such a request.
I'm not really sure why you bring the example up. People don't in fact get extradited from Iceland to Sudan, so it's not as if it highlights a problem with the present system.
>The Nigerian scammer is still committing fraud, but in Nigeria.
I don't see how that is necessarily the case, if the victims are in other locations.
- mindslight 10y ago> Your previous comment certainly appeared to misunderstand dual criminality since you thought it was relevant whether or not Lauri had been convicted of a crime in the UK An action can only be an offense if it illegal. And something can only be illegal if found so in a court of law. So, in abstract, dual criminality would require a proper trial in the extraditing country to determine if an offense was committed. The actual implementation takes shortcuts (because bureaucrats' goal is focused on achieving punishment), but this is an erosion of the legal system as I've been pointing out. Surely you don't think that someone in a country with due process should be mechanically extradited to a country with no due process, but you're relying on a merciful extradition court to essentially try the case and provide due process before extradition. > I don't see in principle why someone who lived in Iceland but was involved in producing pornography in Sudan should not be extradited for it And distribution? eg just setting up a website that isn't not accessible from Sudan? I made this example because it shows how something can be technically "illegal" in two different places, yet have entirely different criminal procedures and punishments. > I don't see how that is necessarily the case, if the victims are in other locations. I have repeatedly stated that I'm rejecting the idea that communication can create a legal nexus. In this context since the fraudster has not left Nigeria, all his crimes are happening within Nigeria. This has been my main argument the whole time. Rather than directly addressing my main point, you've only countered with how things currently are. Obviously if I thought the current state of affairs was worthwhile I would not be making this argument, so it's hardly a refutation.
- foldr 10y ago>So, in abstract, dual criminality would require a proper trial in the extraditing country to determine if an offense was committed. No, dual criminality requires that the person be extradited for (allegedly) doing something which is a crime in both countries. So for example, you can be extradited from the UK to the US on a murder charge because murder is a crime in both countries. Whether or not you have been found guilty of murder in the UK is irrelevant. >Surely you don't think that someone in a country with due process should be mechanically extradited to a country with no due process, That is why extradition treaties are generally only signed with countries which have due process. But all of these extradition requests have to go before a court; they're not "mechanical". >I have repeatedly stated that I'm rejecting the idea that communication can create a legal nexus. In this context since the fraudster has not left Nigeria, all his crimes are happening within Nigeria. This is just wrong on the face of it, and you've provided no supporting argument. If the fraudster is defrauding people in another country then his is potentially subject to the jurisdiction of that country.
- mindslight 10y ago>> I'm rejecting the idea that communication can create a legal nexus > This is just wrong on the face of it, and you've provided no supporting argument All of my comments have contained the supporting arguments, to which you've merely responded with how things currently are. This does not make for much of a refutation. IMHO this is one of the problems with a common law legal system. It's all too easy to forget that its various principles and precedents are actually man made and not manifest immutable truths.
- foldr 10y agoYour arguments were based on various hypothetical scenarios (extradition to Sudan on pornography charges, etc. etc.), which could not happen in the present system due to some combination of (i) the dual criminality requirement, (ii) the probable non-existence of the relevant extradition treaties, and (iii) the discretion that courts have to refuse extradition requests to countries which are unlikely to give a fair trial, or where disproportionate penalties are applied.