4 ms·
from original article: "One of the most striking features of chemistry as a science is that very palpable properties like color, smell, taste and elemental sta
by dnautics 10y ago
from original article: "One of the most striking features of chemistry as a science is that very palpable properties like color, smell, taste and elemental state are directly connected to molecular structure."
If the lab notebook doesn't contain that information, no amount of machine learning will find it. There's also intuition in subtle things that don't necessarily make it into the lab notebook (did I shake the extractor vigorously or just a little bit?). Or when running on autopilot, maybe you didn't do something that you wrote down you did - that makes a difference.
If you could automate lab note taking, that would be excellent.
Moreover, this 'principles based search' in the subthread article is about crystallization, which is notorious for being a tractable solution based on high-throughput methodologies (and thus has massive parallelization as a worked out strategy). Synthesis, by contrast, is a low-n experience. When machine learning techniques get good at classification by solving MNIST by looking at 3-5 samples of each letter, then maybe I'll be more optimistic.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago>> One of the most striking features of chemistry as a science is that very palpable properties like color, smell, taste and elemental state are directly connected to molecular structure. That doesn't sound so striking. Smell and taste are both direct physical assessments of molecular structure. There's no model where they could fail to be related to molecular structure.
- dnautics 10y agoYeah that's in the Op's linked article, but would be unaddressed by the sub thread linked article's technique.
- dharma1 10y agohttps://arxiv.org/abs/1507.02672 https://arxiv.org/abs/1507.02672 Ladder networks get 1.62% error rate on MNIST with 50 labeled samples