5 ms·
The problematic migrant situation in Europe is a good example of that. Is it? Are illegal immigrants more likely to cause problems that both natives and legal
by icebraining 10y ago
The problematic migrant situation in Europe is a good example of that.
Is it? Are illegal immigrants more likely to cause problems that both natives and legal immigrants? From what I can tell, at least the attacks that make the news have all been perpetrated by people born and raised in Europe.
EDIT: http://www.dw.com/en/report-refugees-have-not-increased-crime-rate-in-germany/a-18848890 http://www.dw.com/en/report-refugees-have-not-increased-crim...
- zajd 10y agoWell you have to understand that when white Europeans complain about "immigrants" what they really mean is "brown people". It's 2016 baby, thinly veiled racism is the name of the game. edit. I'm sure with these downvotes someone will come answer your question... lol
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoI don't know if that's entirely fair, the pro-Brexit people had strong opinions about Poles and Italians too.
- zajd 10y agoEh the pro-brexit people probably feel they're brown anyways.
- detritus 10y agoBased on what - your own prejudice? I think people in Britain, and indeed many 'white' countries, are less bothered by the colour of one's skin than the tone of their culture and intent behind their immigrating. If you're not coming here to integrate, but just coming for money and with no thought of being part of my culture, why on Earth would I joyously welcome you? What would be said if I were to move to somewhere like the middle east and insist upon being a cider-swilling yob? . Disclaimer: My partner is Italian and I'm a cider-swilling British yob. Well, a bit of a boor at least.
- zajd 10y agoWords like "tone of their culture" are exactly the problem. Can you imagine if you weren't allowed to travel somewhere because of the tone of your culture? Do you enjoy being restricted from travelling to Saudi Arabia because you popped out of the wrong vagina? I'm not from the UK but I can tell you firmly that words like "black culture" are just racist dogwhistles here in the US
- detritus 10y agoTravel, or permanently relocate? There's a distinction - quite massive one. No one gives a hoot about tourists. And I meant with the self-denigration in my post to imply that my own 'culture' has its own tone - as indeed does every culture. It's a question of whether they have the potential to be inter-compatible.
- zajd 10y agoAnd my point is that compatibility should be measured on an individual basis, not based on where you happened to be born. Assuming that all people from one place share a culture is what got us into this mess in the first place.
- detritus 10y agoIt isn't already? And if it's not by individual reckoning, what construct from upon ahigh would you suggest be instituted to make these decisions en-masse, outwith local consensus? All people from one place do generally share a culture, generally speaking - sure, any atomisation of said generalisation will throw up exceptions, but that doesn't make the generality any less valid in its local context. We're monkeys - somewhat illogical meatsacks bound to our nature and emotions - not robots able to rewrite our own truths to fit some other's sense of hyper-morality. Sorry, that's not reality. - ed Cripes that was a garbled response. Sorry - long weekend..
- zajd 10y ago
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y ago"Begin at Calais" and all that.
- tdkl 10y agoCologne rape happened after this article, so did the massacres in France and Germany.
- pas 10y agoFYI, those are still just data points. If you extend the timeframe - which naturally we want to - we need to include all the data for the interval.
- icebraining 10y agoWhich of the massacres were perpetrated by refugees or illegal immigrants? The Nice attack was made by a legal immigrant, living in France for more than a decade. The Brussels ISIL cell members were almost all born in Belgium, France or Sweden. The Charlie Hebdo shooters were born in France, as was the guy who took those hostages in the supermarket. The Munich shooter was born in Germany. Which ones am I missing?
- pzh 10y agoBorn in France doesn't mean socially and culturally integrated. Many of these attackers were children of immigrants who either didn't integrate because of their own cultural beliefs or because the host society didn't provide the necessary conditions. Whatever the reason, these people didn't feel like they belong to the host societies and radicalized. If anything, these attacks are examples of unsuccessful integration and of the failures of free movement and immigration of people of radically different cultural beliefs, and not the other way around.