4 ms·
How far do you take this? If I see someone in a car throw some trash at a bicyclist, and then swerve and knock the cyclist off the road...should I not give a de
by tzs 10y ago
How far do you take this? If I see someone in a car throw some trash at a bicyclist, and then swerve and knock the cyclist off the road...should I not give a description of the car and driver to the police?
Or suppose a child disappears on the way home from school. Police ask people along the child's normal route if they saw her that day (they are trying to narrow down where she may have been abducted). I was out mowing the lawn that afternoon and did see her walk by, and know the time to within 5 minutes. Should I not tell the police?
In prior discussions of this video on other forums, people have told me that based on it they would in fact not say anything in the above examples. If people won't tell the police these kind of things, it is going to be a lot easier to persuade people to support pervasive public surveillance.
- perlgeek 10y agoIf this becomes pervasive, maybe there'll be some legislation that protects the population better from the police?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 10y agoYes. Remember that a lawyer only represents his client. The missing child is not his client. His client is the person on the street. That said, every interaction with police increasing your risk. If your only interest is in your own legal wellbeing, don't talk. In the cases of things like missing kids, there are normally anonymous tip lines for missing children. Beware the situation where there is no tip line. Cops are not above claiming to be searching for a lost kid when in reality they are looking for people who were on the street at a particular time. "I didn't see her" is an admission that you were there, which may result in a not-good interrogation as to some other things that happened. You may now be on their list of suspects for whatever they are actually investigating.
- rayiner 10y ago> I was out mowing the lawn that afternoon and did see her walk by, and know the time to within 5 minutes. Should I not tell the police? You do not want to be the last person who saw a missing kid.
- dazc 10y agoWhen I lived in the UK I had a friend with mental issues and as a result he would come into police contact on a regular basis. Most often than not he would be making some sort of claim that obviously wasn't true and the police would want to talk to someone more responsible just to confirm that this was a 'mental health issue' so they could walk away without fear of any comeback. As a friend I was happy to take this role even though it could get embarrassing. On one occasion the officer concerned actually seemed to be concerned about my friends welfare. In most of the other instances (at least half a dozen times) all they wanted was an excuse to get the hell away. A couple of times it was more sinister though and I got the feeling that the police were hinting that I was guilty of something. My friend has confirmed to me that on some occasions they would try to put words in his mouth. He acts like an idiot sometimes but he's no fool either. As a consequence I have told my friend that if he gets into trouble with the police again he can't ask me to speak on his behalf. I worry what will become of him but I just don't have faith in the police anymore. So, OK your examples are extreme, but I would be wary of talking to the police in any situation again.
- jjoonathan 10y agoHow the hell are you supposed to behave? Police officers have the informal authority to make your life miserable (detaining for 24hrs without cause, selective enforcement, the ability to lie both to you and the court and be taken at their word, etc). No lawyer is going to advise talking to the police, but there's clearly an element of selection bias in that. In cases that don't wind up requiring a lawyer, cooperation with the person who has this power over you is almost certainly to your benefit. The real question is how to draw the line, and all the lawyerly "never say a word to the police ever unless you're invoking the 5th" really doesn't help.
- tptacek 10y agoMost people just talk to the police. The overwhelming majority of interactions with police are benign. Consider avoiding police interactions if you are black/latino and not a resident of the neighborhood where the interaction occurs; if the police are knocking on your door or doing something else that deliberately involves them confronting you; if you carry or have casual access to firearms or contraband; if you have any criminal record. Statistically, most people don't fall into these buckets and thus don't land in the fact patterns that generate the majority of abusive interactions. I know it's hard to believe on Internet message boards, but in majority-minority neighborhoods in the US, the primary complaint residents have with the police is that they aren't doing enough. (I do not also mean to say that residents of black neighborhoods aren't also concerned that the police will casually murder them in tense/hostile confrontations, because that is a real concern as well).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]