3 ms·
IANAL, but my understanding of the supreme court decision is that if you stop answering questions, that can be presented to a jury as evidence that you may be g
by aidenn0 10y ago
IANAL, but my understanding of the supreme court decision is that if you stop answering questions, that can be presented to a jury as evidence that you may be guilty. A stupid example:
Q: Did you kill Alice?
A: No.
Q: Did you kill Bob?
A: No.
Q: Did you kill Carol?
A: silence
They can then make the argument in court that since you stopped answering questions at the 3rd one that you are trying to hide something. This is why the advice is to just straight up refuse to answer any questions without a lawyer. "I want a lawyer" is not refusing to answer the question, just delaying it, so may not be covered by the current precedent.
- mark212 10y agoI am a lawyer, and a former prosecutor and former defense attorney (I do civil law now). And invocation of your right to counsel is supposed to terminate all questioning. Very clear that it cannot be presented as evidence if the matter goes to trial.
- aidenn0 10y agoMy understanding is that in Salinas v. Texas the issue was that the defendant did not explicitly invoke this right, but was quiet; though apparently, at least one of the Justices was of the opinion that the 5th amendment rights do not apply when the person being questioned is not being detained.