3 ms·
This hits home for me as a musician myself. I have often lamented overly prescriptive scores, for example something from Eric Whitacre. Granted, they are often
by hammock 10y ago
This hits home for me as a musician myself. I have often lamented overly prescriptive scores, for example something from Eric Whitacre. Granted, they are often intended for high school choirs where you have an inexperienced director directing inexperienced singers, so the composer is trying to exert some (needed?) quality control over the end product. But a good director, or even better a good singer, doesn't need every single phrase punctuated by a crescendo and decrescendo, for example. It's patronizing.
Similarly, in a given song you may find an ascending line marked/not marked with a decrescendo. What this means is simply "fight the natural tendency to get louder as you approach a higher tessitura." Sometimes this is marked and sometimes it's not. If it's not marked, a bad singer will plow through thoughtlessly (or worse, misinterpret and get even louder as if it were a great big cadence). If it is marked a bad singer might take it too literally.
Experience, critical thinking and good, well-rounded musicianship can help you make these performance decisions. But those skills and qualities are becoming rarer. Not just in the field of music, either.