13 ms·
> then solving 1 CAPTCHA now allows a robot to do 100x the work it did before The point of a CAPTCHA is to validate that the person browsing a website is a hum
by belorn 10y ago
> then solving 1 CAPTCHA now allows a robot to do 100x the work it did before
The point of a CAPTCHA is to validate that the person browsing a website is a human being. Once they have done that, the person can click on 1 page, 100x pages, or 1000x pages on the site, and from a security perspective that is the same result. The goal was to identify the nature of the entity behind the request, not limit how many times the person accessed the site.
If a server accepts to sign 100 tokens per CAPTCHA, it means that the server assumes those 100 tokens represent the same human person. It do not allow a robot to do 100x more work than before unless the captcha is so faulty that the assumption is incorrect, in which case the captcha is broken and should be replaced. A captcha that only work 90% of the times is not actually preventing bots, since bot owners can easily just add 10x more bots.
- greglindahl 10y ago1) Bot sends the CAPTCHA to a human (perhaps using https://de-captcher.com/ https://de-captcher.com/) 2) Have the bot crawl 100 pages 3) ...
- mrb 10y agoLet me reexplain the threat model that I see. Consuming one token bypasses the need to solve one CAPTCHA. Now you have heard about people being hired to solve CAPTCHAs, right? Well with these tokens, every time a human solves one CAPTCHA and obtains 100 tokens, it's as if he helped a robot bypass 100 CAPTCHAs. Other example: say a CAPTCHA system is so good that only 0.1% of its challenges can be solved by a robot. With these tokens, if 100 are signed per solved CAPTCHA, then it's as if the robot could solve 10% of them. A 100x improvement.