3 ms·
First, it would be nice if the currently closed parts of a the Google-logo Android most OEMs ship were more open. Google's IoT OS is developed in the open, whil
by Zigurd 10y ago
First, it would be nice if the currently closed parts of a the Google-logo Android most OEMs ship were more open. Google's IoT OS is developed in the open, while AOSP has periodic updates. Parts of Google's suite of services and apps that are currently for Google-logo OEMs could also be opened without weakening Google's position with OEMs.
Secondly, it would be nice if there were more smartphone OS choices, like Jolla, that could prosper alongside the two main choices.
But Google doesn't deserve to get fined for anti-competitive practices. Amazon's mobile OS drafts off of Google's work on AOSP, and nobody is whining about that. Yandex announced they would do something similar. Chinese OEMs have long had their own app stores on Android. In many ways Android is the basis for open competition in mobile OSs.
If you want something other than the Google ecosystem, you can have it on an Android OS with all the latest OS technologies. But you have to have your own credible ecosystem and customer base for it. I'm not sure what the EU wants that hasn't already been demonstrated can be done in the US, Russia, and China.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoYandex is behind the Russian case against Google , because OEMs told Yandex that Google forbid them from working with Yandex. In Russia, Google's already been ordered to make the changes the EU is demanding here, though there's no signs Google has complied yet. China only has competition because Google doesn't operate there. Amazon's Fire Phone shows how successful one can compete with an international monopoly. None of these are good examples to defend Google, and in fact, demonstrate why it's so crucial Google be taken down a peg. Honestly, they don't deserve a fine, because they can afford it, and it's no big deal. Google needs to be forcibly broken up into smaller parts, and banned from colluding with each other. It's time to do to El Goog what the US did to Ma Bell.
- Zigurd 10y agoRegarding "because OEMs told Yandex that Google forbid them from working with Yandex" that appears to be true. Google forbids OEMs from selling both Google-logo and other-ecosystem devices. Google's excuse is "anti-fragmentation." They do this to make OEMs accept Google's decisions about Android, and either you are in or you are out. But that's not a high barrier. Amazon's tablets are made by some CM/ODM who most likely manufactures Android devices for a number of OEMs. Yandex could have private label phones much the same way. Or they could get phones from China OEMs that don't care about making Google-logo devices. The Amazon Fire phone was as much a turkey as Echo is a hit. It wasn't Google's fault. As for China, Google does operate there now, and Lenovo sells Google-logo Androids in China. But the non-Google ecosystems continue.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThe Fire Phone was definitely hugely impacted by not having access to the apps which only the Play Store has (most of them), and the fact that, specifically, Google's own apps are only available through them. Who's going to buy a phone without YouTube? Similarly, if you look at reviews of Windows Phone, most are very positive, with one exception: Without Google providing good support for the platform, people don't want to use it. Google's monopolies span far and wide, and it's difficult for anyone in the tech industry Google refuses to work with. As far as the Echo... Google hasn't even released Google Home yet, and they're already telling manufacturers they're going to have to choose between supporting Alexa and supporting Google Home. If China has Google now, it's still not a huge problem: Lenovo is only a small part of the market share there, and most importantly: All of the apps popular in China are already available in other stores. Maybe we should ban the Play Store for a few years in the US until the same situation happens here?
- Zigurd 10y agoI bought a Fire tablet without YouTube. Amazon has their own media ecosystem. Almost all the mass-market apps I use are available on the Amazon app store. Even Netflix. I would, however, agree that it is petty, pointless, and possibly counterproductive for Google not to put apps that use the Google ecosystem on Amazon's app store. As far as what the Fire phone was missing? I'd say maps and navigation. They should have gotten HERE on board at launch.