3 ms·
Thanks. I would file that Vidal debate under examples of conversations that dove right off the rails, though it is maybe his most famous. I think there might ha
by brownbat 10y ago
Thanks. I would file that Vidal debate under examples of conversations that dove right off the rails, though it is maybe his most famous. I think there might have been some with Chomsky too.
The Hitchens discussions were better, even though they were very far apart politically.*
And he had some with sitting Democratic politicians where he would occasionally make concessions. Towards the end here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5-R2aHdul0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5-R2aHdul0
Though he starts by setting up an unproductive definitional trap about liberalism, a recurring theme, he basically backs off after being called on it (roughly 4:55).
It's unfortunate that that full conversation (and really, more Firing Line) isn't on YouTube so we'd have more case studies.
* Perhaps ironically, because Hitchens became a lot more sympathetic to Buckley's views on military intervention and skepticism of Communism later in his career. I think that's to Hitchens' credit though, that he was able to continue turning these issues over in his mind and apply them differently to different contexts.