4 ms·
I am not sure why everyone cares so much about flash infrastructure. I go to Penn Station to ride the train from time to time. It's fine. You can get a coffe
by jrockway 10y ago
I am not sure why everyone cares so much about flash infrastructure. I go to Penn Station to ride the train from time to time. It's fine. You can get a coffee down there. You buy a ticket and get on your train. It's not a work of art, it's not a beautiful space that inspires me to be excellent. But I don't expect it to be, it's a train station. I go there to get on the train.
Trump was droning on about this during the debate, how our airports make us look like a third-world country or something. I don't see why anyone cares. I've taken numerous flights in and out of Laguardia. You show up there, go through security, and get on an airplane. I am not looking for excitement or a work of art. It's an airport. I want to be in and out as quickly as possible.
I only want two transportation-related improvements -- more service so I can get a seat during the day and not wait around for 30 minutes at night, and positive train control so that I don't die when someone forgets to stop at the last station. Everything else is ego-driven money wasting. (I'm looking at you, Andrew Cuomo.)
- mancerayder 10y agoRead icehawk's comment below regarding infrastructure. It's not the lack of works of art, architectural details, or coffee shops that's the issue. As an occasional rider you don't know, but the station hasn't scaled its ridership over the years. Coming up from the tracks or down to there, during rush hour or even a typical weekend, is a slow nightmare. Frequently commuters coming up and down colide and cause a deadlock, as there are no designated up and down areas. The layout is old. The station is large and poorly organized. I was in a very busy station with a bad rap in London a few weeks ago, called Victoria, and while the British complain about everything this station handles multiple commuter lines and several Tube lines with sophisticated aplomb. It's wide and open, like I see the new Penn design is intended to be. It's not an issue of beauty, it's an issue of efficiency and scale. The infrastructure hasn't scaled.
- Symbiote 10y agoI think it just proves your point: Victoria Underground Station is considered overcrowded, and is being upgraded at the moment with the construction of additional entrances. It looks like everything new will be underground, so there's not so much room for beauty. Unlike my memories of NYC, it will at least be very well lit and kept clean. https://tfl.gov.uk/travel-information/improvements-and-projects/victoria https://tfl.gov.uk/travel-information/improvements-and-proje... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Victoria_station#Current_upgrade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Victoria_station#Curren...
- mancerayder 10y agoYou make me jealous of my time in London. My main complaints when I lived in London (in East-Central London, in E1W): a) long east-west travel times b) no overnight Tube options c) (though less important) no A/C on the Tube, are ALL being addressed. It's depressing and sad that a city with three times the GDP (per the last time I checked), NYC, my now-home, has a shoddy and corrupt, slow-moving infrastructure upgrade plan. Every infrastructure plan costs smaller-country-budget levels of spend, takes longer than expected, and after the ribbon is cut is still behind its competition (because let's face it, international cities compete) in Europe and Asia.
- cfmcdonald 10y agoYou could take a similar utilitarian view of all structures, and come the the conclusion that there's no reason for anything to be beautiful or inspiring.
- mancerayder 10y agoBut that view would be suspect, since tourists like pretty things, and tourists have pretty dollar bills. Pretty stuff is attractive to business because it attracts potential customers. Rich people like to live near pretty things, making property expensive. Witness the expensive neighborhoods in NYC (eg. Central Park perimeter) and London (green, leafy, old, Kensington, Chelsea, St James, etc.). Utilitarian, in the dictionary definition ("designed to be useful instead of attractive") is the opposite of these places. Utiliarianism, the greatest good for the greatest many, is a different story for these places. I feel like that's what you meant. Your suggested conclusion might be better paired with a utilitarian approach?
- humanrebar 10y agoLaGuardia's issue isn't its ugliness but its lack of efficiency: not enough seating, not enough A/C outlets, long waits to get through security, not enough bathrooms, dangerous triple-parked quick-rearrange-the-luggage-so-we-can-go pickup-and-dropoff areas. The dinginess of the terminals and dearth of food/shopping options are really bad too, but the biggest problems in my opinion have to do with objective issues that any stoic efficiency expert would balk at.