3 ms·
Maybe IQ rises because people are learning to take IQ tests. I read in some HN posting: in the 40's folks registered ~70 on IQ tests (old tests found in drawers
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
Maybe IQ rises because people are learning to take IQ tests. I read in some HN posting: in the 40's folks registered ~70 on IQ tests (old tests found in drawers at some University). The questions were 'trick questions' and the test-takers weren't familiar, so answered pragmatically and were marked wrong.
Example: "There are no Rhinos in Germany. Munich is in Germany. How many Rhinos are in Munich? A) 0 B) 1 C) 3 D)other"
Folks would answer B. We imagine they are thinking "Well Munich is a big city, and probably has a zoo. There would be at least one Rhino in the zoo." Are they wrong? As an "IQ test question" they're wrong. But as a real-world issue, they're on the right track.
Today people have encountered trick questions by the time they take IQ tests, so they do better. That might be all there is to it.
- John23832 10y ago> Maybe IQ rises because people are learning to take IQ tests. That's a pretty interesting thought. You could actually apply that to a lot of "trainable" personal metrics.
- mcguire 10y agoInterestingly, the article supports that hypothesis.
- Jtsummers 10y agoFor questions like that, it's less that it's a trick question (unless you're familiar with the Munich Zoo), than that you are only supposed to take the constraints of the problem as presented. The situation is presented as a hypothetical, it's not a trick, it's an abstraction that (many) people have trouble with. Like getting students to understand that a figure in a geometric sketch isn't precise, it's just representative, look at the numbers included to actually understand it.
- barrkel 10y agoIf it's abstract, why does it use a real place in the question? Answering the question correctly is in fact predicated on a sophisticated assumption of how this particular type of question is constructed: using metaphors of real life to construct abstract scenarios to test arithmetic or logical predicates. You need to know that it's abstract, and that the construction of the abstract scenario is by metaphor with reality.