3 ms·
When banks are held responsible its the people who end up losing money. You can't just let them be when they struggle because you'll end up paying double. It d
by dogma1138 10y ago
When banks are held responsible its the people who end up losing money.
You can't just let them be when they struggle because you'll end up paying double.
It doesn't mean that banks don't end up "paying" especially if there was misconduct but it's not as simple as just giving them a cold shoulder.
- camperman 10y ago"When banks are held responsible its the people who end up losing money." If a bank is insolvent, as it looks like Deutsche Bank is, you've _already_ lost your money. "You can't just let them be when they struggle because you'll end up paying double." Bailing them out means paying double if they lose your money making stupid loans or ridiculous bets and then they get bailed out with taxpayers' money. They were already in deep trouble eight years ago and were bailed out. What did they do with that lifeline? Placed even more ridiculous bets with it, bringing in the bonuses but expanding the bank's debt to a whopping $42 trillion. Besides, banks aren't special. They're businesses like any other. They need to go bankrupt if they make stupid business decisions. "It doesn't mean that banks don't end up "paying" especially if there was misconduct but it's not as simple as just giving them a cold shoulder." No of Wall Street executives prosecuted for the financial crisis of 2008: 0.
- dogma1138 10y agoThere is lost your money, and there is lost your money. Technically once you gave money to the bank you've lost it, what you've gained is a body that would tell other people on your behalf "it's ok i got him covered". Once you can't use an ATM, can't pay bills with direct debit, can't do anything then you've effectively lost your money. The problem is that DB is a commercial high street bank, and not only that it's one of the biggest banks in the world and across Europe. Overall all the banks in Europe are in a mess http://ei.marketwatch.com//Multimedia/2016/09/28/Photos/NS/MW-EW741_wolfst_20160928053102_NS.jpg http://ei.marketwatch.com//Multimedia/2016/09/28/Photos/NS/M... and it's not entirerly due to their fault, the negative interest rates implemented by the central banks didn't really help. Please save us the sentiment which is actually likely to be out of place here because people have somewhat incorrect analogy to wall street and 2008 and say the banks are guilty, their employees/managers are criminally negligent and they should be put on trial. DB isn't LB on many levels, it's haunted by it's ghosts, but what plagues it and every other major European bank is not the same, and in this case they aren't the only body at fault, the policies of the ECB and the local central banks in Europe so far were pretty devastating for the banks.
- sjclemmy 10y ago> Besides, banks aren't special. They're businesses like any other. They need to go bankrupt if they make stupid business decisions. I disagree. Banks form the foundation of the infrastructure of the capitalist system. Failure of banks has a large effect on the businesses that rely on that system to operate.
- cmurf 10y agoIs it really a capitalist system if the foundational infrastructure is ultimately public (the state), not private?
- sjclemmy 10y agoYes it is. Capitalism doesn't mean an absence of government or make any distinction between private or public ownership, it simply means that the way resources are distributed is through a market system. In order for the market to operate a means of exchange that we all agree upon and trust is required. This is money. Banks manage the market system's means of exchange. If something happens that impedes the exchange, the system is compromised.
- cmurf 10y agocapitalism: an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state. That's the dictionary definition. What you're talking about is "the free market" - which is not the same thing as capitalism.
- sjclemmy 10y agoIf we are nit picking... What I am talking about is free market capitalism. The definition you quote talks about trade and industry - which we can reduce down to calling the means of production. Capitalism is about ownership of the means of production for private gain. It doesn't exclude government ownership of resources / means of production or indeed and perhaps most importantly the money system. I think you could even argue that public ownership of the money system facilitates the capitalist economy. What does the central bank / federal reserve do?
- Loic 10y agoAs a simple customer of the bank, your money there is ensured up to €100k. If you own stocks, you own them in full you can move them away without issues. So, I would say, for most people in a country, if a single bank fails, you have nothing to worry. If many banks fail, this is another story as they insurance pool of the banks may dry out.
- dogma1138 10y agoInsurance takes time to claim, when banks fail the financial services stop functioning, when your payments don't clear you are at considerably greater risk than when a bank is insolvent and can't consolidate it's outstanding accounts with the central or its peering banks. Commerzbank is in almost of a bad shape as DB, same goes for many other banks in the EU and Germany. Greece was a nightmare people don't really understand what was going on and the fact that they couldn't use an ATM, couldn't pay their bills, but at least that was a country wide issue. When you get a similar situation but when one out of X people is left hanging in the wind because their bank has failed it would be considerably worse since there would not be a single unified emergency solution to cover them (in greece people stuck it out, there was even bartering, local stores had credit ledgers etc, GL getting credit from your local supermarket because your DB debit card won't work anymore), and when more banks start to fail because their investors and creditors lose faith and pull out (which is what happened to LB) it would make things worse and worse.
- kbart 10y ago"Insurance takes time to claim" It's less than 20 days by law in my country and almost everything is done without depositor's input -- money are transferred to another bank and you simply come there with your ID to take your money in cash or open an account in another bank. I really wouldn't mind to wait a week or two as opposed to billions paid of tax money.
- blahi 10y agoAs someone living in a country where one of the biggest banks was robbed to fund hostile takeovers and media propaganda for many years (€3Bn spent on that), I can assure you that the law means jack shit.
- kafkaesq 10y agoWhen banks are held responsible its the people who end up losing money. "When banks knowingly engage in irresponsible, or in Deutsche's case, criminal behavior it's people who end up losing money" is the spin I would put on it.