2 ms·
My mistake, I thought the carefully-constructed dilemma was an attempt to avoid begging the question. Now it seems you're perfectly content to make that mistake
by jessaustin 10y ago
My mistake, I thought the carefully-constructed dilemma was an attempt to avoid begging the question. Now it seems you're perfectly content to make that mistake; never mind.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoWhat mistake? It is routine to make claims about the world that might end up being true or false. Bald assertions don't become logically fallacious because you choose to call them "begging the question". As best as I understand your comment, you think I need to avoid defining "useful results" of a definition of evolutionary change in terms of whether those results support a distinction between living fossils and novel species. (I am in fact not defining them this way.) I've claimed that of the four possibilities: 1. Our sense of "change" is scientifically fruitful, and "living fossils" are identifiable. 2. Our sense of "change" is scientifically useless, but "living fossils" are identifiable. 3. Our sense of "change" is scientifically fruitful, and "living fossils" are not distinctive. 4. Our sense of "change" is scientifically useless, and "living fossils" are not distinctive. only (2) and (3) can occur. I could make this claim a tautology by defining "useful results" as "results which do not support the concept of 'living fossils'", but there is no reason to do that. Rather, in the event of an observation in category (1), I'd be wrong. In my original wording, I have claimed that (4) cannot occur. That is, obviously, untrue, and that explains the parenthetical notes I attached. I'm relying on the implicit premise that when someone chooses a measurement of evolutionary change, they have some goal in mind, and therefore they will not choose a measurement that does not meet their goal.