3 ms·
Note that Rust statically links in everything it needs by default, which is why hello world is so much larger in Rust than in C. :) If you want a hello world bi
by kibwen 10y ago
Note that Rust statically links in everything it needs by default, which is why hello world is so much larger in Rust than in C. :) If you want a hello world binary that's as small as C, there is a compiler flag for dynamically linking the generated binary.
- PowerGuido87 10y agoA statically linked hello world in C using the MS toolchain gives me a 77Kb binary. The C++ version, using std::cout, is 176Kb.
- steveklabnik 10y agoIt's not clear (though it seems like no?) that the parent used options like LTO that would reduce the binary size.
- brainspider 10y agoI just literally installed the compiler toolset and did the first demo in the tutorial. I have never seen anything so large before, but I'm not a coder and not a windows coder. The only windows code I have compiled has been FreePascal and that wasn't this crazy. Similar to what sebcat showed above, I've done a bit of assembly on systems 8bit and up including nasm on linux, so not used to binaries with this sort of baggage. Wasn't trying to paint rust in a negative light, just came as a surprise when I ran that first compile.
- steveklabnik 10y agoIt's all good! I'm not assuming any malice. First impressions are also very important.
- sebcat 10y ago5344 byte statically linked hello world in C: $ musl-gcc -static -Os -s -o hello hello.c $ ls -la hello -rwxrwxr-x. 1 sebastian sebastian 5344 Sep 30 06:22 hello $ ldd hello not a dynamic executable $ ./hello Hello, World 384 Byte hello world using NASM and ld on linux/amd64: BITS 64 global _start %define SYS_write 1 %define SYS_exit 60 %define STDOUT_FILENO 1 section .text _start: call after strHello: db 'Hello, World!',10 lenHello equ $-strHello after: pop rsi mov rdx, lenHello mov rax, SYS_write mov rdi, STDOUT_FILENO syscall mov rax, SYS_exit xor rdi, rdi syscall Most of the size overhead in the latter example comes from the ELF header, so by paying a bit more attention to the linker scripts, or just inlining a small ELF header with db in the asm file, it would be even smaller. Just for size comparison. I am sure that it's quite possible to generate small Rust binaries as well.
- kibwen 10y ago> I am sure that it's quite possible to generate small Rust > binaries as well. Indeed, here's a 151-byte hello world[0] in Rust: http://mainisusuallyafunction.blogspot.com/2015/01/151-byte-static-linux-binary-in-rust.html http://mainisusuallyafunction.blogspot.com/2015/01/151-byte-...