2 ms·
The author has seriously underestimated (or, more likely, overlooked) the difficulty of a key step in his proposal: enumerating all possible circumstances. How
by mannykannot 10y ago
The author has seriously underestimated (or, more likely, overlooked) the difficulty of a key step in his proposal: enumerating all possible circumstances. How many different "truck crossing ahead" scenarios are there? How many different ways might something be misidentified as the sky? or something else? How many combinations of basic errors are there, in which the basic errors themselves may be harmless, but the combination is not? Even deciding whether two cases are the same or different is often a matter of opinion, and it is further complicated by the fact that what is the same or different to a given system depends on details of the implementation of that system.
The author is not shy about making other assumptions, either: "Sebastian Thrun postulates that, when subject to real-world conditions, AI can double its performance every 18 months" "let’s assume that a driverless car is perfect at navigating scenarios it has previously handled safely"... The foundations of this article's argument are not nearly as sound as the author seems to think.