4 ms·
Since they didn't seem to specify religious jews, their survey is just mixing ethnic with belief group, which doesn't make much sense.
by golergka 10y ago
Since they didn't seem to specify religious jews, their survey is just mixing ethnic with belief group, which doesn't make much sense.
- dsr_ 10y agoThey are measuring perceptions, which are all inside people's heads. If they had included "lizard people" and "foreigners" on the survey, that would also be a valid way of measuring perceptions even though one group represents 7 billion people and the other zero.
- irrational 10y agoIsn't this the case with most of the groups? I would imagine even atheist Jews have been to synagogue at least a few times. I would consider Catholics who only go to Easter and Christmas mass to not be religious.
- jedberg 10y agoThe difference is that Jewish is actually an ethnic group as well as a religious group. There is some overlap between them of course, but for example there are Asian Jews and Jewish Catholics. The Jewish ethnic group are people historically descended from the people of Eastern Europe and the Middle East who practiced ancient Judaism (the religion). That's why 23andme can identify someone as X% Jewish.