5 ms·
As someone in the hard tech space I can tell you that it's not completely irrational on their part. When you look at exits and probabilities of exits, the types
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
As someone in the hard tech space I can tell you that it's not completely irrational on their part. When you look at exits and probabilities of exits, the types of software companies you describe make up the bulk.
The biggest (by val) technology startups that we know of (Uber, Lyft, AirBnB, Snapchat, Dropbox, Pinterest) are by no means hard tech. Even the public ones aren't hard tech (Facebook, Linkedin, Twitter). So that's what these investors look to as the types of investments that make sense for them.
The question is, do hard tech companies have similar probabilities of outcomes or bigger?
- purplelobster 10y agoI'd say Google was hard tech
- Animats 10y agoGoogle was working, using Stanford resources, before it was funded. Low investor technical risk. Also, Google's founders had patent coverage of their idea.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nostrademons 10y agoDropBox was hard-tech when it came out; they reverse engineered the Finder so that your DropBox folder would appear like a normal Mac folder. They may seem like a commodity now because everybody's doing stuff like that (and in many cases, APIs have appeared that make it trivial), but when they first launched, they did stuff most people assumed was impossible. Twitch/Justin.TV was also hard-tech when it came out, though now the hard parts are built into every iPhone. Other than that, I largely agree. The last software hard-tech company to strike it really big was Google. There've been a number of open-source projects doing what I'd consider hard-tech software, though - Bitcoin, git/Mercurial/Darcs, Bittorrent, TensorFlow, etc. (My definition of hard tech, as applied to software, is "Software where you need to use scientific-method trial-and-error to build core pieces of the product." If you can read an online tutorial or reference manual and build the product, it's not hard tech. If you need to poke around at things, observe the responses, and build your own model of how things work, it is.)
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoMy definition of hard tech, as applied to software, is "Software where you need to use scientific-method trial-and-error to build core pieces of the product." I think that's a great definition actually and fits with how ML systems are built.
- DannyBee 10y ago"DropBox was hard-tech when it came out; they reverse engineered the Finder so that your DropBox folder would appear like a normal Mac folder. " This, IMHO, is a really bad example. This is pretty much just a few days of sitting in GDB for the right engineer[1]. Now, maybe it require people experienced with debugging tools, but it's really not "hard tech". Now, productionizing it so it works on all versions, yeah, a bit trickier. but again, none of this is at the level of basically "understanding how to make custom bacteria that do a thing", etc. If this is the example you mean for "did stuff people assumed was impossible", then i strongly disagree. ""Software where you need to use scientific-method trial-and-error to build core pieces of the product."" This, IMHO, is way too low a bar. By this definition, the clang compiler we built for windows is "hard-tech". While it requires time and energy and trial and error, that is not hard, in the same way the dropbox stuff is not hard. It is known that it is possible, and requires the reasonable application of good engineering skill. That engineering skill may often involve the scientific method trial-and-error, but you know you will eventually get there. The same is true of dropbox, and in particular, your finder example. The only thing unknown is the timeline, and even that you can take a reasonable stab at if you have good enough engineers. [1] I did it before they did, and i wasn't even the first. Plenty of people have made this happen :)
- jrsnyder 10y agoMicrosoft (operating system, SQL database, programming languages / environments) and Oracle (databases, partial credit for programming language (Java)) could be considered hard-tech software companies with outcomes (so far) that are many multiples of those you mentioned.
- cft 10y agoThose ones (along with Google and Microsoft that are arguable hard tech) were founded prior to web 2.0. Since about 2002 no hard tech software startups achieved any scale- they are sort of all "moving up the stack". When they emerged (Android Inc) they are promptly swallowed. In the mid-2000s there were Yelp (from the software perspective, a simple website with Lucene backend and Youtube - a simple website with Flash player and ffmpeg transcoding command). It's probably a sign of consolidation of the industry.
- mrDmrTmrJ 10y agoUsing Sama's definition of a hard-tech product or business as "where there is doubt that the technology can be built at all", a bunch of successes come to mind. 1. Tesla (Market Cap ~$29B w/$14B+ in pre-orders) 2. SpaceX (Valued north of $10B) Elon's companies faced massive doubts about tech feasibility, both when started and at basically every-point since. 3. Oculus. Sold for $2B in March 2014, including $1.6B in FB stock that's now worth 2x more. 4. Machine Zone The messaging platform for Game of War/Mobile Strike is very "hard tech". (Google/AWS still lack equivalents and MZ was kinda forced to take a "time out" to develop it.) In 2014 the WSJ said they where fundraising at close to $3B and now their cash flow powers global TV add campaigns. 5. Cruise. "Hard Tech" and a big win for YC. 6. Zoox. They started w/a prototype and have made huge progress. Many new business lines at public companies faced huge doubts about tech feasibility and are now clear home runs: 7. Nvidia Every new chip is "hard tech" and they've grown massively in the last decade. 8. iPhone/Apple + Android Inc. Smartphones are really, really, "hard tech". So many doubts on both the tech and product side are now forgotten! 9. Google (mentioned by others) In addition to search/adds/Android, I'd say maps/gmail/infrastructure/android are all examples of "hard tech". Each was viewed as "hard tech" when released. (Contrast Google Maps w/Apple's disastrous maps launch years latter.) 10. AWS If you had pitched AWS as a startup, in late 2003, you would have faced lots and lots of technology skepticism. A phenomenal success. 11. Amazon Echo Hard tech, took a massive team to develop. Doing great as a product. Crossing "the valley of death" in commercializing new tech is really hard. But there are vast success!