3 ms·
> Whether it's a stolen car, drugs, or money made from selling a stolen car and drugs. It's all (mostly) similar. It's not that similar IMO. Stolen cars have
by wyldfire 10y ago
> Whether it's a stolen car, drugs, or money made from selling a stolen car and drugs. It's all (mostly) similar.
It's not that similar IMO. Stolen cars have owners to whom you can return the property, or litigants who can sue you to replace it. But selling contraband, unlike theft, doesn't have a victim that can be compensated by returning the proceeds. The government steps in and declares themselves the victims of this crime and claims the proceeds.
- ocschwar 10y agoSo far so good. The problem is they do it before convicting you of anything.
- brianwawok 10y agoYes, this is obviously a problem. I think holding it during a trial could be reasonable, but the burden of guilt should not be "guilty until proven innocent"
- wfo 10y agoActually, worse: they seize your assets so that you cannot afford to mount a solid defense at your trial. It's a lot easier to convince someone to take a plea (i.e. confess falsely under duress) if they are bankrupt and destitute and can't afford proper counsel.
- adekok 10y ago> But selling contraband, unlike theft, doesn't have a victim that can be compensated by returning the proceeds. The point is largely that people shouldn't legally profit from illegal activities. Whether the profit is cash or tangible goods, the principle is the same.