6 ms·
To be fair, avoiding the fries and shake (or chips and coke or what have you) seems to cut 50% or more of the calories. 760 calories on a burger is a fine porti
by komali2 10y ago
To be fair, avoiding the fries and shake (or chips and coke or what have you) seems to cut 50% or more of the calories. 760 calories on a burger is a fine portion. Then again, the macro ratio is probably not where you want it if you're counting that sort of thing.
- ng12 10y agoThe macros on a burger are actually pretty good. Lots of protein, lots of fat, 30-40 carbs. In-n-Out was one of my post workout go-to's when I was really paying attention to my diet.
- croon 10y agoThe McDouble has been touted as well as a !/$ macro comp [1]. [1]: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/foodanddrink/10210327/McDouble-is-cheapest-and-most-nutritious-food-in-human-history.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/foodanddrink/10210327/McDouble-is...
- spicytunacone 10y agoI'd be careful with that claim. Looking at the nutritional info on the In-N-Out website[0], I wouldn't say the macros are pretty good at all. Let's take the Double Double which clocks in at 670 total calories, a decently sized meal as the parent comment would suggest. Double Double Total Calories: 670 [520 Protein® Style (lettuce for bun)] Fats: 41g (18g from saturated fats) * 9 = 369 calories, ~55% [~68%] Carbs: 39g * 4 = 156 calories, ~23% [~7%] Protein: 37g * 4 = 148 calories, ~22% [~25%] For comparison, Cheeseburger Total Calories: 480 [330 Protein® Style] Fats: 27g (10g from saturated fats) * 9 = 243 calories, ~50% [~68%] Carbs: 39g * 4 = 156 calories, ~32% [~13%] Protein: 22g (a normal Hamburger is only 16g) * 4 = 88 calories, ~18% [~22%, total calories using my crude calculations adds up to 341] Now, I realize arguing about ratios is about as good as arguing about editors, but, for bulking, I'd rather scarf down some milk and I still think that's a tad extreme (its ratios come to about 30% fat/45% carbs/25% protein even at a quarter gallon for a comparable 632 calories)[1][2]. As for cutting to preserve lean mass, it's definitely not something you can easily put into your day without some prior planning or fallback options. Personally a Double Double would put me at only slightly north of 1kcal allowance on a cut, and I'd need to get another >~100g protein to come near my goals. Obviously I'm not saying someone can't enjoy a burger every so often, but I wouldn't suggest they compose model macros for most purposes. 0: http://www.in-n-out.com/nutrition.aspx http://www.in-n-out.com/nutrition.aspx 1: https://fitness.stackexchange.com/questions/3967/weight-gained-using-gomad-strategy https://fitness.stackexchange.com/questions/3967/weight-gain... 2: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1/4+gallon+milk http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1/4+gallon+milk tldr: amateur bodybuilder (me) doesn't think fast-food burgers are particularly great on their own, even for gaining mass. If you're a non-bodybuilder/don't care about macros, just watch the sodium and saturated fats if anything.
- ng12 10y agoIt depends on your diet goals. For me the 7% carbs was the attractive part.
- spicytunacone 10y agoYou specified the "30-40[g] carbs", which is the proper, bunned burger (as opposed to the 11g carbs on the lettuce version). I realize I am being a jerk, but I don't want people to walk away from reading comments like this convinced that a burger can be a staple of their diet without some scrutiny. I'm in CA and in particular I have talked with enough people who believe that because they chose In-n-Out over whatever other franchise that they are "eating healthy".
- ng12 10y agoWho said anything about protein style? 40g of carbs is 40g of carbs, which is a totally healthy amount for a meal. Anyways, the point was that a hamburger can totally be a part of a healthy diet and it's the fries/soda/shake that get you. Edit: ah I see, I misread the chart. Still, a quick burger is a convenient option even if you're watching calorie intake.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> 760 calories on a burger is a fine portion. Depends; most people should not be eating 2000 calories a day, because most people don't burn anywhere near that many calories a day with activity.
- projektir 10y agoYou don't burn most of your calories with activity. You burn them by existing. The average male gets pretty close to 2k calories consumed a day with no activity, depending on their height.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Depends; most people should not be eating 2000 calories a day, because most people don't burn anywhere near that many calories a day with activity. I think the averages are about 1500 for women and 1650 for men even before activity (that is, just basal metabolic rate). +500kcal/day from activity isn't a huge amount. I run about 2300 kcal/day BMR (I'm, well, not a small guy), and average somewhere around 3500 kcal/day total, and I'm not super active.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> I think the averages are about 1500 for women and 1650 for men even before activity (that is, just basal metabolic rate). +500kcal/day from activity isn't a huge amount. That's the average, which means many people are below that average. And even if you consistently eat 2000 calories and burn 1650, you'll steadily gain weight. A large number of people are almost completely sedentary.
- projektir 10y ago1650 sounds catastrophically low for male, where did you get that number from? I'm seeing as high as 2500 on some websites for a sedentary male... Not a great source but: http://www.webmd.com/diet/features/estimated-calorie-requirement http://www.webmd.com/diet/features/estimated-calorie-require...
- 10y ago
- charlesism 10y agoLook at the chart again: the common denominator for all the worst foods there is refined wheat. Take a look at the pasta dish! Having said that, a food's glycemic index is also a factor. You could feed the big steak in that photo to a diabetic, no problem at all. You'll be digesting that steak for the rest of your day. The bag of chips on the other hand, well you might as well use a syringe and inject the sugar right into your arteries.
- dpark 10y agoMany of the foods shown have little to no wheat in them. The common factors are high fat and huge portions. Fats are not bad for you but they do make it easier to overconsume because they are more calorie dense. Huge portions are also not strictly bad for you because you could just not eat it all, but the reality is that bigger portions lead to overeating. That pasta dish is just entirely too much food. It's fried chicken and creamy sauce and yes a lot of pasta.
- charlesism 10y agoAs far as I can see, almost all the foods that don't have wheat have sugar, which I assumed everyone knows is bad. The remaining five "bad" dishes are potato-based, which is another starch (ie: sugar)
- dpark 10y agoSo basically you're anti-carb. You started with the claim that "the common denominator for all the worst foods there is refined wheat" and now you're dragging in potatoes and sugar. If you're anti-carb, that's fine I guess, but it's utterly irrelevant to why these meals are "bad". They're bad because they are too many calories. Wheat is a minor component of almost all of them. There's nearly as many calories in the chips and guac from Chipotle as in the burrito. Even in the flour tortilla, nearly a third of the calories are actually from fat (and it's only 300 calories total). In the steak and martini from Ruth's Chris, there's no wheat, no sugar, no starch at all. It's still 2000 calories and a third of that from fat. In that absurd milkshake from Sonic, there's no wheat. More than half the calories are from the fat, which is pretty impressive considering how much sugar is in it. Even that pasta from the Cheesecake Factory has over a third of its calories from fat. I find it amazing that even the IHOP breakfast has more than half its calories from fat, considering it literally has a pile of wheat in the form of pancakes. The idea that refined wheat could somehow be responsible for the caloric excess of most of these dishes is absurd. Most have little or no wheat. They all have too many calories.