3 ms·
Kudos to Google for being smart enough to realize that an open web is a win for them in the long run and for having the guts to compete on the strength of their
by cageface 17y ago
Kudos to Google for being smart enough to realize that an open web is a win for them in the long run and for having the guts to compete on the strength of their products and not on platform/api lock-in. Obviously it's still an uphill battle to get this adopted across the board but they're setting the right example here.
- niravs 17y agoBoth Chrome & Firefox are supporting this from the beginning. It's certainly a great start.
- cracell 17y agoI can't find any official word that Firefox is supporting it. This article simply says it expects Firefox's will because of Firefox's reason for not supporting h.264 was that it wasn't open license.
- sketerpot 17y agoGiven how much caterwauling there's been about Firefox not supporting H.264 and the problems with Theora, I'd be very surprised if Firefox doesn't support VP8 soon after it's open-sourced. Too many people want it too badly for it not to happen.
- irrelative 17y agoI agree, but it would have been a less steep uphill battle if they had done this 7 months ago.
- vetinari 17y agoThe merger was finished this February, so they weren't in position to do this 7 months ago.
- nkassis 17y agoI'm glad that their interest of reaching a wider user base to advertise too is also in sync with creating an open platform like the web. They can keep the Ad platform secret, nobody will care as long as they keep doing things like this.
- andreyf 17y agoAt launch, On2 went so far as to claim that it could provide “50 percent bandwidth savings compared to leading H.264 implementations.” Considering the amount of bandwidth Google spends on streaming YouTube content, this move is far from altruistic. The more viewers adopt a bandwidth-superior format, the less terabytes of data to stream, the less the cost of running YouTube. They have absolutely no benefit from any kind of "platform/api lockin" to H.264 or any other video standard, only that there are less bits to stream. I don't see how it's an "uphill battle" to convince anyone they should use a free standard instead of paying million of dollars in licensing fees per year. I'd expect Microsoft to ship this instead of H.264 in the next major IE, and, if this comes with a good and open hardware interpreter, Apple to follow soon after.
- jmillikin 17y agoConsidering the amount of bandwidth Google spends on streaming YouTube content, this move is far from altruistic. Who cares? Companies are allowed to make the world a better place without having to self-flagellate themselves. Google could easily have just paid the H.264 licensing fees and told Mozilla to toss off, or even built VP8 support into Chrome and used YouTube to force-feed it to the world. They chose to cooperate, and should be praised for that. I don't see how it's an "uphill battle" to convince anyone they should use a free standard instead of paying million of dollars in licensing fees Several companies, most notably Apple, have already spent what must be millions of dollars on licensing fees and hardware. Regardless of which is a better long-term choice, it can be very difficult to reverse that much momentum. Not to mention the hundreds of millions of non-consumer multimedia equipment which is designed to use H.264. Additionally, VP8 does not have much application support yet. It'll take a while for codecs to be written, debugged, and distributed to users. There may be significant lag time before VP8 displaces Theora among F/OSS users, or H.264 on OS X.
- allyt 17y agoThey chose the path that would lead to the fastest adoption of the technology which lowers their bandwidth costs. Keeping the technology Chrome-only is against their financial interests. Apple and MS pay yearly licensing fees for H.264. As soon as they adopt VP8, they can stop.