6 ms·
Somebody in the area should offer to help them out. Someone who knew what they were doing could pretty easily suck the whole thing into an emulator, and that wo
by jerf 10y ago
Somebody in the area should offer to help them out. Someone who knew what they were doing could pretty easily suck the whole thing into an emulator, and that would keep them going probably for the next several decades, if they like, without having to worry that the hardware going out will cause them problems, or that the disks will crap out.
(I'd consider it myself but I'm about 2400 miles away.)
- ThinkBeat 10y agoSince it is used for balancing, I assume it interface with some hardware. Getting the hardware to work and finding a compatible port could be difficult, unless its just serial or parallel ports
- jerf 10y agoI think you might be surprised by how active the Commodore community has been. I haven't checked every possible component before writing this message but I'd bet the Commodore hardware ports are all available and can be hooked up to emulators just fine. And you can stockpile those for not much money right now. And while they, too, will have correlated failures over the course of decades as they decay, at least it starts the clock back at 0 again.
- cnvogel 10y ago> I'd bet the Commodore hardware ports are all > available and can be hooked up to emulators just fine. You are aware that the C64 expansion port is actually the 6510-CPUs address and data-bus? To properly emulate this cycle accurate in an emulator you'd have to attach about 30 I/O pins to your PC which you can update at a rate of 1MHz, with basically no latency between reads and writes, to connect external circuitry.
- mrob 10y agoEven if it doesn't need realtime performance, which it might, it's interfacing with custom hardware, so it's going to be tricky to emulate. This is more the kind of thing you'd use an Arduino for. The Arduino's old-fashioned 5V IO is probably useful in this case.
- anarcat 10y agoYou are assuming they need help. It seems to me they are doing fine. Whatever your thing will run on, will it still work in another 30 years? Our hardware is so flaky that everyone in the industry is depreciating at 3-5 years or less. Sure, platforms can stay the same, hardware-wise, but you'd be really lucky if you can still run the same software that you did before. And yes, you can run an emulator, but who's going to maintain the underlying platform? Is it going to be connected to the internet and be part of the next gargantuan IoT DDOS attack. What those guys is need is another Comodore 64, brand new. It has proven it works, why change it? We need to take a serious look at this stuff: this is what we should be doing. Not writing yet another freaking web server, but stuff that can still be operational in 30 years.
- jerf 10y ago"You are assuming they need help. It seems to me they are doing fine." Are you responsible for a production deployment of any kind? "I'm doing fine until something goes wrong" is not doing fine. Unfortunately, merely stockpiling Commodore hardware is not a great long-term plan; the failures will be correlated. Even the ones just sitting on the shelf are decaying. "And yes, you can run an emulator, but who's going to maintain the underlying platform? Is it going to be connected to the internet and be part of the next gargantuan IoT DDOS attack." Why would it be? You seem to be really, really stretching for reasons why this is a bad idea.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoPretty much guaranteed that nothing someone would build for them today would last them 3 decades. That's a lost art.
- Scarblac 10y agoThere probably exist COTS things to do exactly what they use this C64 for, used by other garages. When the day comes that this thing runs out, they can always switch to one of those. That's probably a better idea than trying to get this to work in a C64 emulator, timing issues and all.
- 10y ago
- blihp 10y agoWhat gives you the impression that they need help? Other than (potentially) the floppy drive, every other part of that computer is both more reliable (low power, low temps) and easier to repair (through hole) than anything they could get today. As an added benefit, they get security through absolute obsolescence. They should keep using what they've got until it no longer suits their needs or it becomes infeasible to keep it running.
- btbuildem 10y agoPretty sure they'd curse you out of the shop if you went there to propose that.. Their setup has been working for decades, it's more secure than 99.9% of systems out there, and the cost has long since amortized.
- vidarh 10y agoI'd be willing to bet that it will be easier to replace failing components or the whole thing to keep their system running for the next several decades than trying to keep a PC based replacement with an emulator running for the same amount of time. You can buy entire newly built motherboards for the C64, as well as tons of spare parts and a number of FPGA reimplementations. All/most of which are basically static, with no fans, and at least for the stuff that depends on original chips, it's pretty much indestructible. E.g. just consider the dust, and the heat produced by most modern PCs vs. a fan-less c64 where the internals rarely get very hot. And where the components for the most part are near indestructible as confirmed by 7-8 year old me repeatedly pulling them out of their sockets helped by screwdrivers and reseating them and occasionally bending pins, without and kind of regard for static electricity; I also carried out "experiments" like moving chips between my C64, Amiga 500 and 1541 with little disregard for just how pin compatible they were. I amazingly never destroyed any of them. In terms of the disks, you can still buy suitable floppies for backups, and you can also buy 1541 replacements that use SD cards or compact flash. 30 years from now, I bet you'll still be able to buy "C64s" in some form, while to keep a system based on a current PC it'd be hard not to get sucked into an upgrade cycle.