3 ms·
When I was at university (UBC) "pre-Clovis" was an almost forbidden word in some classes. I saw a very heated debate in a geology class discussing land bridges
by sandworm101 10y ago
When I was at university (UBC) "pre-Clovis" was an almost forbidden word in some classes. I saw a very heated debate in a geology class discussing land bridges. Many First Nations students took issue with any suggestion that their nations, their cultures, were not "first". Why that matters I don't know (politics) but they were adamant supporters of the Clovis First hypothesis. It has taken many years to etch away at the underlying land bridge assumptions and properly credit the resourcefulness of ancient peoples.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clovis_culture#Clovis_First_.2F_Single_origin_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clovis_culture#Clovis_First_.2...
- frozenport 10y agoBecause the white man took their land in the same way their ancestors took the pre-Clovis culture's land? Thus, reducing the sympathy, tax-breaks, other lucrative financial advantages they were able to secure?
- mootothemax 10y ago>Why that matters I don't know (politics) but they were adamant supporters of the Clovis First hypothesis. I imagine that it's less about "being first," and more about not wanting a history of hideous exploitation to be washed out under the excuse of you weren't first. I try to imagine what it must be like to only have had my family's history recognised in any meaningful way in very modern times - and then to have people tell me "no no no, actually that's all changed, this is your narrative now." Rightly or wrongly, I think I'd be on the defensive as well.
- simonh 10y ago>Many First Nations students took issue with any suggestion that their nations, their cultures, were not "first". We've every reason to suppose that contemporary Native American people are every much descendants and inheritors of the legacy of any pre-Clovis people, as they are of the Clovis culture. It's all part of their heritage. I can see how drawing artificial distinctions like that could be used as derogatory arguments against them though. A slur doesn't have to be valid to still be hurtful. Still, it seems a shame to feel forced into a position in which you feel compelled to denigrate or denying the legacy of people, some of which are almost certainly your own ancestors.