3 ms·
This is a bizarre argument to me. Economists, for instance, do not have an agreed-upon definition for the "money supply". Nevertheless, it is perfectly reasonab
by nerdponx 10y ago
This is a bizarre argument to me. Economists, for instance, do not have an agreed-upon definition for the "money supply". Nevertheless, it is perfectly reasonable to operate as if such a definition existed, so long as the details of its definition or not important in the discussion.
Similarly, this is in the same vein as writing pseudocode containing a function that has not yet been defined. The exact execution steps of the program are not defined, but you can still reason about its flow all the same.
To say that we cann't determine whether a species has changed, because we don't have a meaningful way to measure species change, is fine. It does not follow, however, that species change is inherently unmeasurable, and that therefore we just can't talk about it at all.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> It does not follow, however, that species change is inherently unmeasurable, and that therefore we just can't talk about it at all. Sure, and I didn't say or imply that anywhere. I said that no matter how you conceptualize evolutionary change, the concept "living fossil" will be nonsense.