3 ms·
Cheese is more than just tolerable: by reducing the amount of lactose present, it turns milk into a food for lactose-intolerant adults. It is thought that adult
by mannykannot 10y ago
Cheese is more than just tolerable: by reducing the amount of lactose present, it turns milk into a food for lactose-intolerant adults. It is thought that adult lactose intolerance was the primal state of humanity, and that cheese consumption was a step on the way to adult tolerance, in those cultures that developed it.
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v493/n7433/abs/nature11698.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v493/n7433/abs/nature11...
- hyperpallium 10y agoYes, and lactose tolerance in adulthood seems to have evolved quite recently (7000 BC IIRC). Of course, human infants are already lactose tolerant (so they can suckle). I'm guessing the switch-off evolvee for involuntary weening, and had survival value. I believe bread, beer and wine pre-date cheese, and so the idea of a transformation through some agent wasn't that far-fetched. And milk obviously is nutritous. I'm not sure, but can you make sorta cheese, in the way that rotting fruit is natural fermentation, and dough can rise from wild-yeast (and unlevened bread was being eaten already). Once the idea is born, you can work to improve it. It's easy to think of primitive humans as dummies, but they were probably smarter than most of us, and once they got an idea, they would tweak it. Plus, it only takes one clever and lucky person in a network of communities to hit on an improvement, for it to spread. But there's a question of why the lactose tolerant mutation spread so widely... was there a starvation event? An outcompeting, or invasion by stronger, milk-fed warriors? But I expect cheese making eating was very wide-spread well before this event, and it was a great source of calories. Blessed are the cheese makers.
- masklinn 10y ago> But there's a question of why the lactose tolerant mutation spread so widely... was there a starvation event? An outcompeting, or invasion by stronger, milk-fed warriors? It seems calorical contribution was the main factor in sub-saharan africa but in europe (the other main source of the mutation) it is mostly linked to vitamin D deficiency (the mutation spread from areas with less sun, especially inland areas with limited access to fish).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 10y ago> It is thought that adult lactose intolerance was the primal state of humanity It's not just a thought, the lactose tolerance mutations have been reasonably well tracked in time and space. > cheese consumption was a step on the way to adult tolerance, in those cultures that developed it. That however doesn't make much sense, most cheese-based cultures remain broadly lactose-intolerant. Some of the earliest cheese evidences come from the middle-east, northern africa and central asia, which have limited to very limited rates of adult lactase persistence. If you look at Europe's map of lactase persistence, rates fall as you head south, where the oldest evidence of cheese-making cultures are, cheese spread from the south but lactase persistence spread from the north (Roman authors specifically recorded germanic tribes/cultures as drinkers of raw milk), more closely linked to vitamin D intake necessity.