3 ms·
Here's a measurement of "change" that really doesn't seem to have such dastardly motivations: body mass. I.e., if a species is much larger than its ancestors, i
by jessaustin 10y ago
Here's a measurement of "change" that really doesn't seem to have such dastardly motivations: body mass. I.e., if a species is much larger than its ancestors, it has changed a bunch. If not, it hasn't. On which horn of your dilemma will you try to catch me?
- thaumasiotes 10y agoThe first. It's very easy to show species with similar body mass that anyone sane would characterize as being very different from each other. What analysis will benefit by treating all similarly-massed descendant species of some clade as equivalent to each other, while those with different mass are different?
- jessaustin 10y agoNo that doesn't work. The first horn was all about motivation, which you don't mention here. You can't change the dilemma now. You used a perfectly reasonable technique to avoid providing a definition yourself; it just didn't work this time.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoWhat motivated your choice of body mass? Feel free to adjust my remarks to, second, "if your definition was motivated honestly"; and first, "otherwise". You're not winning any points by saying "ah, but my motivation of trying to show you up is, unlike 'defending the concept of a living fossil', a useful scientific purpose'. As I have already pointed out twice below my first comment, the point of the dilemma is to illustrate that no definition of evolutionary change from which it is possible to extract useful information can support the concept of "living fossils". Which particular motivation you want to use, other than learning something useful, doesn't really matter. From a more formal philosophical perspective, I see no real need to have my description of the dilemma be so careful as to explicitly mention a motivation that can't exist in the absence of my presentation of the dilemma. I am satisfied to have accurately described the world as it exists in the absence of my description of it. You'll note that you did in fact observe one of the two things I predicted.
- jessaustin 10y agoMy mistake, I thought the carefully-constructed dilemma was an attempt to avoid begging the question. Now it seems you're perfectly content to make that mistake; never mind.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoWhat mistake? It is routine to make claims about the world that might end up being true or false. Bald assertions don't become logically fallacious because you choose to call them "begging the question". As best as I understand your comment, you think I need to avoid defining "useful results" of a definition of evolutionary change in terms of whether those results support a distinction between living fossils and novel species. (I am in fact not defining them this way.) I've claimed that of the four possibilities: 1. Our sense of "change" is scientifically fruitful, and "living fossils" are identifiable. 2. Our sense of "change" is scientifically useless, but "living fossils" are identifiable. 3. Our sense of "change" is scientifically fruitful, and "living fossils" are not distinctive. 4. Our sense of "change" is scientifically useless, and "living fossils" are not distinctive. only (2) and (3) can occur. I could make this claim a tautology by defining "useful results" as "results which do not support the concept of 'living fossils'", but there is no reason to do that. Rather, in the event of an observation in category (1), I'd be wrong. In my original wording, I have claimed that (4) cannot occur. That is, obviously, untrue, and that explains the parenthetical notes I attached. I'm relying on the implicit premise that when someone chooses a measurement of evolutionary change, they have some goal in mind, and therefore they will not choose a measurement that does not meet their goal.