4 ms·
There's More to Science Than Evolution
- jacquesm 17y agoThe reason why evolution stands out in contrast to other questions is because the church never got around to making a 'genesis' that flat out contradicts the size of an electron or how lasers function, and then turned this in to a central piece of their doctrine that supports a whole pile of other religious concepts. Also, evolution operates on time-scales that most humans have trouble perceiving and/or thinking about so it is a convenient concept to create doubt around, even if it is one of the best supported scientific theories out there.
- torial 17y ago"even if it is one of the best supported scientific theories out there." While it certainly has more evidence than AGW, it doesn't hold a candle to relativity (general or specific) or newtonian physics or a whole slew of chemistry theories. I do agree w/ the first part of that sentence, that the large time scales are hard for people to wrap their mind around, and thus lends itself to a natural doubt of it.
- pmiller2 17y ago"...it doesn't hold a candle to relativity (general or specific) or newtonian physics or a whole slew of chemistry theories." I don't know if that's necessarily true. It's certainly not possible to measure how "accurate" the theory of evolution is, because it's not that kind of theory. It doesn't really make many (any?) specific predictions that can be tested in the same manner that those of relativity or chemistry can. On the other hand, I think our odds of discovering something tomorrow (or even in the next hundred years) that cannot be reconciled against evolution are significantly lower than the odds of us discovering something in the same timeframe that's inconsistent with relativity.
- torial 17y agoWe can't borrow from knowledge we'll have tomorrow, any conjecture on what will be found is at best a hypothesis in its own right. Data and verification for relativity is just well established (but arguably more research dollars go into that than evolution). Viewing the odds of discovering something tomorrow or the next hundred years is very subjective -- case in point, I view the odds of discovering something contradictory to evolution far higher than something contradicting relativity. So we are at an impasse, and I'd suggest we need to go on what we have now, rather than how something might unfold based on our own biases (I am not denying my inclination towards astrophysics!). If evolution could be harnessed to make verifiable predictions, I think it would be further along in terms of being a grounded and less disputed theory (with the understanding that no matter what, there will be dissenters). Or if alien life was found, I think evolution science would benefit from having a second playing field and might be on a better footing.
- jacquesm 17y ago> If evolution could be harnessed to make verifiable predictions That's an 'ID' talking point and verifiable false. There are many thousands of cases where evolutionary theory could be used to predict the outcome of an experiment and each and every one of those has held up. The interesting one would be the first -and only- counter example required, but to date not a single one has been found. Support for evolution is rock solid, to the point where the only people that try to undermine it usually have some kind of political agenda to push. You have to hand it to the ID (formerly creationist) groups though, they are doing an excellent job of sowing doubt amongst the uneducated, and they are getting skilled at the debate to the point where all but the most interested lay people can see the holes in their arguments. But when they go to hospital and need treatment suddenly science is a-ok and never mind the fact that these bacteria have evolved to become resistant to such and such an anti-biotic, give me the stronger stuff... Your viewing of the 'odds' of something turning up that would contradict relativity is at odds with that of for instance, one Albert Einstein, who searched for a way of unifying general relativity with electromagnetism, without success. Once found it is widely believed that either one or both of the 'parent' theories will need some adjustment. Evolutionary theory is much more vulnerable to falsification, a single example of a creature that could not have evolved and it would be history. In spite of millions of species that we can observe today and the many very motivated people searching for such a counter example none has been found.